CPD defends garment wage proposal in Bangladesh amid industry dispute
Bangladesh's debate over garment sector pay is intensifying as the minimum wage methodology comes under fresh scrutiny. The Centre for Policy Dialogue says governance problems such as the energy crisis, high interest rates and corruption should be addressed separately rather than used to suppress workers' wages.
Highlights
- CPD defended its proposed minimum wage range of Tk18,578 to Tk24,204 for Bangladesh garment workers, advocating a method balancing worker needs and economic conditions.
- CPD argued that using Household Income and Expenditure Survey 2022 data ensures consistency in poverty-line calculations, challenging BGMEA's critique over household and expenditure estimates.
- CPD called for a large, scientifically sampled survey and adherence to Section 141 of the Bangladesh Labour Act 2006, while supporting wage increases but opposing industrial unrest.
Wage methodology and policy dispute
As reported by The Business Standard, the Centre for Policy Dialogue issued its response on 22 November after the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association criticised the think tank's wage analysis presented at a media briefing on 18 November. CPD maintained that the Wage Board should weigh workers' needs against the country's economic conditions, while not transferring the costs of governance failures onto garment workers.The think tank stood by its proposed minimum wage range of Tk18,578 to Tk24,204 and said constructive exchanges could support an evidence-based and realistic outcome. It defended its use of a median household size of four and 1.58 earning members per household, arguing that the median reduces distortions from unusually high or low values in studies conducted at different times, in different places and with different methods.
CPD acknowledged that those figures do not come from a representative survey and cannot replace one. It also said the Household Income and Expenditure Survey, rather than the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics' Socio-Economic and Demographic Survey 2023, is more relevant for wage setting because it provides detailed data on income, expenditure, consumption and poverty.
Its poverty-line-based calculation uses the urban upper poverty line of Tk4,922 per person for Dhaka Division from HIES 2022. CPD added that using household size and expenditure data from the same survey helps preserve consistency, and said applying the BBS figure of 1.37 urban earning members per household would imply a higher required wage for a single earner if other assumptions remain unchanged.
CPD also said its review draws on multiple sources rather than only its 2023 study of 228 workers from 76 factories. It said the analysis includes findings from surveys of 1,119 workers by ACD and 553 workers by the ILO and UN Women, alongside BBS data, while acknowledging that combining different studies still does not amount to a new representative survey.
Implications for wage setting and the garment sector
On the choice of the Dhaka urban upper poverty line, CPD said many garment workers live in urban and peri-urban industrial zones where they pay rent and buy daily essentials at market prices. It added that the poverty line covers urban areas across Dhaka Division, including industrial centres such as Gazipur and Narayanganj, not just Dhaka city.The organisation said a worker-weighted poverty line could be calculated if BGMEA provides area-wise worker numbers and if corresponding BBS poverty-line data are available. It also rejected BGMEA's claim that housing costs were counted twice, saying house rent was excluded from non-food expenditure and tobacco was removed from food expenditure before essential costs were calculated.
According to CPD, housing was then added separately, while other essential expenses include clothing, utilities, education, transport, personal care and communication. The group called for a large, scientifically sampled survey covering both workers and factories, and said wage decisions should follow Section 141 of the Bangladesh Labour Act 2006, which considers living costs, production costs, productivity, inflation and employers' capacity.
CPD said it supports a wage increase but opposes vandalism, violence and unrest, arguing that such disruption harms workers, the garment industry and the country. The exchange keeps wage policy at the centre of Bangladesh's key export sector, where labour costs, industrial stability and factory competitiveness remain closely linked.
As highlighted earlier, Savar-Ashulia shutdowns underscored how minimum-wage protests can disrupt Bangladesh’s garment production and supply chains.