Rand Mutual Assurance faces governance scrutiny over R32 billion asset consultant process
Governance concerns at Rand Mutual Assurance are escalating after management alerted shareholders to alleged misconduct tied to the selection of an asset management consultant overseeing an estimated R32 billion. The dispute centers on claims that board members and executives may have influenced procurement decisions and blocked wider access to an independent forensic report.
Highlights
- Rand Mutual Assurance's R32 billion asset consultant procurement from July 2024 to November 2025 suffered procedural and governance deficiencies, including scoring irregularities favoring 27four.
- An ENS forensic review found an investment executive served on both RMA's RFP panel and 27four's investment committee in October 2024, creating a conflict of interest and undermining process integrity.
- Management's concerns escalated after the board blocked access to the final ENS report, while ENS identified nine procedural breaches and recommended potential disciplinary action and review of board fiduciary compliance.
Procurement process and forensic findings
As first reported by Moneyweb, management told shareholders in documents dated 15 October 2026 that attempts to address alleged misconduct had failed because of the board's behavior. Rand Mutual Assurance, which administers workers' compensation for employees in the mining, iron, metal and steel industries, says the concerns stem from a procurement exercise to replace Willis Towers Watson as asset consultant.The review of that mandate began in July 2024, when RMA issued a request for proposals as part of what it described as a broader market testing exercise. Four firms were shortlisted, Alexander Forbes, 27four, Selekane and Novare, but the 2024 process was terminated without an award and a second procurement round started in August 2025.
By November 2025, a recommendation had been made to retain Willis Towers Watson for an additional year and appoint 27four for private markets advisory services. Before that recommendation was implemented, however, RMA received an anonymous whistleblower disclosure alleging conflicts of interest and warning of governance, legal, reputational and operational risks.
An independent review covering the period from July 2024 to November 2025 found what management described as material governance and procedural deficiencies across all three phases. In February 2026, ENS was instructed to investigate possible conflicts of interest among RMA personnel, links between staff and bidding entities, and whether the process had been manipulated to favor 27four.
According to the ENS draft findings seen by Moneyweb, one investment executive participated in RFP meetings from 3 October 2024 while still formally serving on 27four's investment committee until 31 October 2024. ENS says that overlap, combined with other irregularities including alleged scoring manipulation favoring 27four and the suppression of management objections, undermined the integrity of the process.
Board response and implications for oversight
Management also told shareholders that once ENS began dealing with the board, the board instructed the law firm not to share further information with management. When management later requested a copy of the final report, it was told the document could not be shared at that stage, deepening concerns over a possible cover-up and delaying implementation of recommended actions.ENS made nine findings in total and said the RFP process was materially compromised by procedural irregularities and was not conducted in a fair, transparent or procedurally sound manner. It also said the recommendation to award the private assets mandate to 27four does not appear justified on the merits and advised RMA to consider disciplinary action against implicated executives, as well as whether senior board members may have breached fiduciary duties.
RMA non-executive director Tjaart Esterhuyse, in a written statement mandated by the board chaired by Thabo Dloti, says the company takes allegations of misconduct and corporate governance concerns extremely seriously. He says RMA has received a whistleblower report and is handling the matter in line with company policies and governance processes, but adds that it would be inappropriate to comment on specific allegations, individuals or potential findings at this stage.
For South Africa's financial and retirement savings ecosystem, the dispute highlights the governance risks attached to large institutional mandates and the controls expected in consultant and advisory appointments. The outcome could shape not only oversight at RMA but also scrutiny of procurement safeguards, conflict management and board accountability across the insurance and asset management sectors.
Our previous report on executive pay trends at JSE Top 200 companies noted that variable compensation for CEOs and CFOs has been rising much faster than fixed pay, with incentive outcomes showing especially sharp increases in the latest period. We also highlighted how recent Companies Act changes tighten governance expectations through mandatory pay-ratio disclosures and binding shareholder votes on remuneration, increasing board and committee accountability.