Dmytro Kharkov

AM Best revises Courtesy Insurance outlook to negative amid underwriting pressure

AM Best revises Courtesy Insurance outlook to negative amid underwriting pressure
Courtesy's outlook turns negative

Courtesy Insurance Company faces a negative outlook on its Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating as underwriting losses and inflation-driven claims costs continue to weigh on performance. AM Best also affirmed the insurer’s A financial strength rating and said pressure on results is expected to persist in the short to medium term across the vehicle service contract sector.

Highlights

  • AM Best revised Courtesy Insurance's Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating outlook to negative from stable, affirming its A Financial Strength Rating with a stable outlook.
  • Courtesy Insurance posted underwriting losses for three consecutive years due to inflation, supply chain disruptions, and higher loss costs, with pressures expected to persist short to medium term.
  • AM Best cited strongly capitalized balance sheet and ongoing parent support from JM Family Enterprises, but flagged risk of further downgrade if underwriting deteriorates or group dynamics shift.

Rating action and performance drivers

As reported by AM Best, the ratings agency revised the outlook to negative from stable for Courtesy’s Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating and affirmed its Financial Strength Rating of A and Long-Term ICR of "a+". The outlook on the Financial Strength Rating remains stable.

The rating action reflects AM Best’s view that Courtesy’s balance sheet strength is very strong, while operating performance remains under pressure relative to peers. The agency said the company has posted underwriting losses in each of the past three years, citing macroeconomic factors, supply chain disruptions, and inflation in parts and labor that have raised loss costs.

AM Best said those pressures are expected to continue over the short to medium term for Courtesy and other firms in the vehicle service contract sector. It added that the company’s underwriting metrics compare unfavorably with similarly assessed peers, although management has put mitigation initiatives in place that are expected to improve results over the medium to long term.

Parent support and downside risks

Despite the weaker outlook on the Long-Term ICR, Courtesy retains a very strong balance sheet, supported by risk-adjusted capitalization, financial flexibility, and consistent surplus growth. AM Best said the insurer also benefits from implicit and explicit support from its ultimate parent, JM Family Enterprises, Inc., including past capital contributions.

The agency assesses Courtesy’s business profile as neutral, reflecting the scale and reach provided by affiliates within the broader organization, and said enterprise risk management is appropriate for the company’s size and operating scope. AM Best said further negative rating action could follow if underwriting metrics continue to deteriorate against warranty composite peers, if the parent’s financial condition changes, or if Courtesy’s strategic role within the group materially shifts.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.