Stewart Title Guaranty de México ratings affirmed by AM Best with stable outlook
Stewart Title Guaranty de México keeps its key insurer credit ratings unchanged as its parent-backed business model continues to underpin the operation. The affirmation comes as the company faces contracting business volume and expected negative results, while AM Best maintains a stable outlook on the insurer.
Highlights
- AM Best affirmed Stewart Title Guaranty de México's Financial Strength Rating of A-, Issuer Credit Rating of 'a-', and 'aaa.MX' Mexico National Scale Rating, all with a stable outlook.
- Gross written premium dropped and the insurer's book of business contracted for a fourth consecutive year, causing negative bottom line results and ongoing profitability pressures.
- AM Best warns negative rating action could occur if high interest rates or a slowing economy significantly erode profitability or cause a material decline in risk-adjusted capitalization.
Rating affirmation and operating support
As reported by AM Best, Stewart Title Guaranty de México, S.A. de C.V. retains its Financial Strength Rating of A- (Excellent), its Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating of "a-" (Excellent) and its Mexico National Scale Rating of "aaa.MX" (Exceptional), all with a stable outlook.The rating agency says the assessment reflects the company’s integration into Stewart Title Guaranty Company, based in Houston, Texas, and the wider Stewart Title Group. On a consolidated basis, the group carries what AM Best assesses as very strong balance sheet strength, alongside adequate operating performance, a neutral business profile and appropriate enterprise risk management.
STGC offers products through subsidiaries across the U.S., the European Union, Australia, Costa Rica and China, in addition to Mexico. Because title insurance is a specialized product and the group follows an institutional strategy, the Mexican unit focuses its sales efforts on business referred by STGC from existing customers, resulting in a limited number of policies each year.
Profitability pressures and downside risks
AM Best says the company has experienced a downward growth trend in capital and surplus, driven by dividend payments from accumulated retained earnings. Past support from STGC has included capital injections, with the most recent in 2012, to strengthen the business when needed.The insurer’s book of business contracts for a fourth consecutive year, with negative bottom line results driven by a significant reduction in gross written premium. The company is implementing an expense reduction plan to offset those pressures, and AM Best expects operating performance at year-end 2026 to remain at its current assessment level, supported by the referred business system.
Although negative results are anticipated, investment income and contained expense reductions are expected to support operations. AM Best says negative rating action could follow if high interest rates and a slowing economy lead to a significant deterioration in operating profitability or a material decline in risk-adjusted capitalization.
Earlier, we discussed AM Best ratings affirmation for NPA Insurance as it built on stronger operating performance in its UK pharmacy-focused business.