MSCI study links rising board equity ownership to stronger long-term shareholder returns

MSCI study links rising board equity ownership to stronger long-term shareholder returns
Board equity boosts returns

Board share ownership is gaining attention as companies review governance practices tied to long-term value creation. A study of 2,137 companies in the MSCI ACWI Index from 2020 to 2025 found that higher and sustained equity stakes by independent directors are associated with stronger shareholder returns and lower volatility.

Highlights

  • A sustained 5% increase in independent directors’ equity ownership over five years correlated with 35–40 percentage points higher cumulative five-year total shareholder return and 50 percentage points higher risk-adjusted returns.
  • When independent directors held more equity than executives, firms experienced 50.9% lower five-year volatility and each 1% annual increase in their holdings was linked to 7.6% higher five-year TSR outperformance.
  • Boards that decreased their equity stakes over five years saw shareholder returns fall by an average of 9.7% and risk-adjusted returns drop 11% relative to peers.

Governance findings from the 2020 to 2025 study

As reported by MSCI, joint research with FCLTGlobal found that companies whose independent directors steadily increased their equity ownership over five years were associated with stronger long-term market performance than peers whose boards did not.

A sustained 5% increase in independent directors’ equity ownership over five years was associated with 35 to 40 percentage points higher cumulative five-year total shareholder return, and about 50 percentage points higher risk-adjusted returns, relative to companies without that growth. The study also found that higher director ownership tracked with 3% higher research and development intensity.

When independent directors held more equity than executives, five-year volatility was 50.9% lower, the research showed. Independent directors’ holdings also showed a stronger link to shareholder value creation than nonexecutive directors’ stakes, with each 1% increase in average annual holdings associated with about 7.6% higher five-year TSR outperformance, versus roughly 4.1% for nonexecutive directors.

Implications for companies and investors

Boards that reduced their equity stakes over five years were associated with weaker outcomes. Shareholder returns fell an average of 9.7%, and risk-adjusted returns declined 11%, relative to peers when independent directors cut their holdings.

Even with that correlation, ownership remains uneven across companies. Nearly one in five businesses in the study had no director equity ownership at all, highlighting a governance gap that may shape board policy reviews.

For companies, the findings suggest board equity ownership may warrant closer scrutiny within broader long-term governance frameworks. Issues likely to come under review include how long directors should be required to hold shares, whether ownership should continue throughout a director’s tenure, and how board stakes compare with executive holdings.

As a reminder, we recently covered the Five Star Bancorp board appointment of Christopher D Myers as a new director.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.