Shoprite moves to unwind Wiese voting structure in R600 million share deal
Shoprite Holdings is seeking shareholder approval for a R600 million share issue to founder Christo Wiese that would dismantle a long-standing control structure giving him voting power well above his economic stake. The proposal comes after a more expensive 2019 attempt failed and would dilute ordinary shareholders by 0.3% if completed.
Highlights
- Shoprite will issue nearly 1.79 million new ordinary shares to Titan Premier Investments in a R600 million deal to collapse Wiese's deferred shares.
- Wiese’s deferred shares, giving him 32.7% voting power with only a 10.68% economic interest, helped pass a R170 million CEO share award despite 46% opposition.
- The revised transaction reduces dilution compared to the failed R3.3 billion 2019 proposal, with seven resolutions to be voted on at a 19 January general meeting.
Share issue plan and voting overhaul
As first reported by Moneyweb, Shoprite plans to issue just under 1.79 million new ordinary shares to Wiese's Titan Premier Investments as part of a transaction to collapse deferred shares created in 2000. Those deferred shares were issued at a nominal value of 0.1 South African cent each and currently give Wiese additional voting rights equal to 32.7% of the retailer's total voting power.Through Titan and Thibault Square Financial Services, Wiese holds a direct economic interest of 10.68% in Shoprite but retains substantially greater influence over shareholder resolutions. That structure has allowed him to help secure approval for contentious proposals even when ordinary shareholders show significant opposition.
The latest example is a special award worth more than R170 million for chief executive Pieter Engelbrecht, designed to retain him for the next six years. At the annual general meeting earlier in November, 46% of ordinary shareholders opposed the CEO Executive Share Plan resolution, but the measure still passed with 70.91% support once the deferred shares were counted.
Shareholder process and market impact
Shoprite first tried to buy back the deferred shares in April 2019 through a proposed R3.3 billion transaction involving 20 million new ordinary shares. That plan required the company not to receive written objections from holders of more than 15% of its shares, excluding Wiese as the related party, but the proposal faced notable shareholder resistance.The retailer says management and an independent board considered feedback from that earlier process and believe the revised terms reflect shareholder concerns more closely. With a market capitalisation of nearly R200 billion, Shoprite is now pursuing a smaller transaction that materially reduces dilution while removing a governance structure that has amplified Wiese's control.
To complete the deal, Shoprite needs seven resolutions to pass at a general meeting. The company plans to send a circular to shareholders on 10 December and hold the meeting on 19 January.
As highlighted earlier, Accor governance pressure intensified after activist fund Parvus urged the board to replace CEO Sébastien Bazin.