BYD faces EU sales ban after Dutch court rules Ti7 infringes JLR Defender design
A Dutch court ruling disrupts BYD's plans to market its Ti7 sport utility vehicle in Europe, handing Jaguar Land Rover an early win in a rare automotive design rights dispute. The temporary injunction bars EU sales of the model for one week, even as the broader case continues and BYD says it will appeal.
Highlights
- District court in The Hague temporarily bans BYD Ti7 sales in the EU, citing infringement of Jaguar Land Rover Defender design rights.
- The injunction lasts only one week as BYD currently lacks concrete EU launch plans for the Ti7, and the court has no jurisdiction over BYD UK.
- BYD's European vehicle sales more than doubled to over 280,000 through September 2023, outpacing Ford, Tesla, and Nissan in the region.
Dutch ruling blocks planned EU launch
As reported by Reuters, the district court in The Hague rules that BYD's seven-seater Ti7 infringes the EU design rights of Jaguar Land Rover's Defender and imposes a temporary injunction preventing sales of the vehicle in the European Union.JLR, a unit of India's Tata Motors, launched the case earlier this year after BYD announced on its UK website that orders for the Ti7 were open, with customer deliveries due to begin in January 2027. BYD launched the Fangchengbao Ti7 in China last year.
In the ruling, the judge says the Ti7 reflects the characteristic and distinctive elements of the Defender's design. The injunction lasts for one week because the court finds that BYD currently has no concrete plans to place the Ti7 on the EU market, while also ruling that it has no jurisdiction over BYD's affiliate in the UK.
JLR says in a statement that it protects its intellectual property and takes legal action when necessary, adding that proceedings remain ongoing. BYD says it strongly disagrees with the decision, maintains that the Ti7 is the product of its own independent design work and says it will pursue an appeal.
Design dispute adds pressure in growing European market
Major automakers rarely go to court in Europe over design rights infringement, and it is also uncommon for such a ruling to emerge so early in proceedings in a case that is still likely to run for some time.Legacy carmakers have long complained that Chinese rivals copy vehicle designs, though few claims have been proven in court. Reuters notes that one of the better-known earlier disputes ended in 2005, when General Motors and Chery settled a case over the Chery QQ, which the U.S. automaker said copied its Chevrolet Spark.
For BYD, the ruling comes as the Chinese carmaker expands rapidly across Europe after launching sales in the region in late 2022. According to ACEA data, its European sales more than doubled to over 280,000 vehicles through September this year from the same period a year earlier, putting it ahead of Ford, Tesla and Nissan.
We have also discussed the broader context around the New Jersey repair law dispute affecting warranty and recall reimbursement rules for dealers.