Congressional crypto lawmakers differ on agency rulemaking as Clarity Act stalls
U.S. lawmakers who backed crypto market structure legislation say Congress has let momentum fade after failing to advance the Clarity Act alongside stablecoin reform. That leaves regulators facing pressure to shape parts of the framework through rulemaking, even as doubts remain over how durable that approach would be.
Highlights
- Sen. Bernie Moreno states regulators could implement about 80% of a crypto framework through rulemaking, but prefers congressional passage of the Clarity Act.
- Rep. French Hill argues that regulatory action lacks the permanence and legal certainty of statute, warning that agency rules face litigation and limited authority.
- Prospects for crypto legislation remain low after the Clarity and GENIUS Acts failed to advance together, with lawmakers signaling stalled momentum but ongoing bipartisan negotiations.
Dispute centers on limits of regulatory action
As reported by The Block, Rep. French Hill and Sen. Bernie Moreno say Congress missed an opportunity to move the Clarity Act when support for the GENIUS Act was stronger, but they differ on how far agencies can go while legislation remains stuck.Speaking separately on Thursday at The Hill and The Block's Capitol Crypto Forum, Moreno says regulators could put in place roughly 80% of a crypto framework through a rigorous rulemaking process that would be harder for a future administration to unwind. He says the Securities and Exchange Commission and Commodity Futures Trading Commission should use the next two years to establish rules, while adding that congressional passage of the Clarity Act remains the preferred route.
Hill, who chairs the House Financial Services Committee, says agency action cannot provide the lasting legal certainty that legislation would offer. He says regulators have broadly followed the aims of market structure proposals since the Clarity Act failed, but warns their authority remains limited because rules can face litigation and do not carry the same force as statute law.
Legislative delays cloud path for crypto framework
Both lawmakers say it was a mistake to advance the GENIUS Act separately from Clarity. Hill says he urged the Senate and the administration last summer to move both measures together in the House, and he continues to back that approach.Moreno says lawmakers failed to capitalize on the momentum created by stablecoin legislation, arguing that the bill became far more complicated as it expanded from 300 pages to 600 pages. He says prospects for progress in the lame-duck session are effectively nonexistent, while Hill is slightly more optimistic but says the chances are not high.
Even so, both signal that negotiations are not finished. Hill says it is encouraging that Rep. Maxine Waters identifies digital asset market structure as an issue she wants to address if elected committee chair, while Moreno says bipartisan talks could restart around the House-passed legislation after earlier negotiations were derailed by disputes tied to President Donald Trump and ethics.
We recently wrote about Backpack licensing approvals as it prepared a regulated U.S. crypto derivatives launch under CFTC oversight.