Bitcoin wallet flaw study exposes up to $106 million to theft risk
Belgian researchers testing a long-known Bitcoin signing flaw found automated attackers can move within seconds when vulnerable funds appear on-chain. Their broader review across six blockchains through June 30, 2024 recovered 3,620 private keys and suggests exposed addresses once held as much as $106 million at peak valuations.
Highlights
- University of Liège researchers demonstrated that Bitcoin wallet nonce reuse enables automated bots to steal funds within seconds, exposing rapid attack risk.
- A cross-chain scan covering Bitcoin, Dogecoin, Ethereum, Litecoin, Bitcoin Cash, and Dash found 3,620 private keys vulnerable to nonce reuse flaws, affecting addresses valued up to $106 million at their peak.
- The study reveals that weak randomness in wallet software poses widespread operational risk, with public mempools enabling continuous, automated exploitation of predictable signing mistakes.
Nonce reuse test reveals rapid bot activity
As reported by CoinDesk, researchers at the University of Liège deliberately funded vulnerable Bitcoin and Ethereum addresses with a few dollars to observe how quickly attackers would react. Vincent Jacquot said Bitcoin transactions targeting the bait addresses began a second or a few seconds after the setup, with at least two competing transactions racing through the mempool to capture the funds.The experiment centers on a signing error involving reused nonces, the random numbers that should be unique for each cryptographic signature. If the same private key signs two transactions with the same nonce, anyone who sees both transactions can calculate the key and seize the associated coins.
To demonstrate the flaw, the researchers sent 7,200 satoshis to each of six newly created addresses and later triggered transactions that reused a nonce. After one address signed a third payment with the same nonce, its remaining 5,200 satoshis were sent to an unknown address in a transaction signed with the exposed private key, and the transfer was confirmed nine minutes later.
Cross-chain scan points to wider crypto security risk
Jacquot and Benoît Donnet, who work at the university's Montefiore Institute, then scanned every ECDSA signature on six blockchains from each network's launch through June 30, 2024 for the same weakness. They recovered 3,620 private keys, including 3,278 on Bitcoin, 195 on Dogecoin, 119 on Ethereum, nine on Litecoin, six on Bitcoin Cash and one on Dash.Fifteen of those keys appeared only when all six blockchains were analyzed together, indicating some wallet software reused nonces across multiple networks. The addresses linked to those 15 keys held just under $2,100 at their peak balances.
The researchers valued each vulnerable address at its highest recorded balance using cryptocurrency prices from Nov. 25, 2024, producing a combined figure of about €101 million, or $106 million. They did not determine how much money was actually stolen, and the estimate assumes attackers reached every address at its richest point without later deposits by victims.
The findings underscore an operational risk for the crypto sector because public mempools let automated bots monitor for predictable wallet mistakes continuously rather than target specific users. The issue also reflects a broader cost of weak randomness in wallet software, after a Coldcard flaw in July allowed attackers to drain 594 BTC in an initial 25-minute sweep.
In a previous article, we explained how Binance hack wallets moved about $600 million in Ether via cross-chain protocols like THORChain.