New York Fed analysis shows Gen Z job seekers underestimate rehiring chances

New York Fed analysis shows Gen Z job seekers underestimate rehiring chances
Gen Z underestimate rehiring odds

Post-pandemic shifts in worker sentiment are clouding how newly unemployed Americans assess their chances of finding another job. Younger workers are driving much of the gap, with those under 30 now tending to underestimate their reemployment prospects despite stronger actual outcomes.

Highlights

  • New York Fed analysis finds post-pandemic job seekers, especially Gen Z, underestimate their rehiring chances compared to actual job-finding rates.
  • For workers under 30, expected job-finding rates moved from 6.3 percentage points above actual outcomes pre-pandemic to 3 percentage points below post-pandemic.
  • After two years in a job, the actual job-loss rate is about half the perceived rate, reflecting lingering layoff anxieties among tenured employees.

Post-pandemic gap in job expectations

As reported by Business Insider, citing the New York Federal Reserve's Liberty Street Economics blog, workers' expectations of how easily they can find a new job have diverged from actual outcomes since the pandemic, based on analysis of the Current Population Survey and the Survey of Consumer Expectations.

Before 2020, expected and actual job-finding rates moved closely together for newly unemployed Americans, defined as people who have been out of work and searching for four weeks or less. The analysis says that relationship has not returned to its earlier pattern, with workers now appearing too pessimistic about their chances of being rehired.

The mismatch is especially pronounced among workers under 30. Before the pandemic, younger workers tended to overstate their expected job-finding rates relative to actual results, but after the pandemic that pattern reversed, with their expectations falling below what later happens in the labor market.

Younger and tenured workers show lasting labor-market scars

For workers under 30, the shift is marked, with expected job-finding rates moving from 6.3 percentage points above actual outcomes before the pandemic to 3 percentage points below them afterward. The analysis points to potential labor-market scarring from 2020, when 25% of workers ages 16 to 24 lost their jobs during the initial shock.

The report also finds that misperceptions extend beyond younger employees. Historically, the longer workers stay in a role, the less likely they are to lose it, yet their perceptions do not fully reflect that increasing stability.

After two years in a job, the actual job-loss rate is about half the perceived job-loss rate, according to the analysis. That suggests workers may still be carrying recession and layoff anxieties into current assessments of job security, including millennials affected by the pullback after the post-pandemic, zero-interest-rate hiring surge.

We recently wrote about the UK youth job crisis, as nearly 1 million 16- to 24-year-olds were classed as Neet.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.