UK rejoining EU could deliver bigger GDP gain than Swiss-style deal, study finds
A new economic study suggests a closer UK relationship with the EU produces sharply different long-term growth outcomes depending on the depth of integration. The analysis indicates full re-entry would generate about twice the economic benefit of a Swiss-style arrangement, with business investment recovery accounting for much of the uplift.
Highlights
- Productivity Institute study finds UK rejoining the EU could boost GDP by 3.7 per cent, equal to about £112 billion annually at 2025 prices.
- Norway- or Swiss-style single market access would increase UK GDP by 1.79 per cent (£54 billion), while a customs union would contribute 1.26 per cent (£38 billion).
- Current UK government deals on food, carbon, and youth exchanges estimated to deliver just a 0.4 per cent GDP uplift, far below deeper integration scenarios.
Study models long-term gains from closer EU ties
As reported by the Financial Times, research from the Productivity Institute finds that rejoining the EU could raise UK GDP by as much as 3.7 per cent in the long term, equivalent to about £112 billion a year at 2025 prices. The paper is led by Manchester University econometrician Jun Du and co-produced with the Centre for Business Prosperity at Aston University.The study estimates that rejoining the single market under arrangements similar to Norway or Switzerland would lift GDP by 1.79 per cent, or about £54 billion in today’s terms, while a customs union would deliver a 1.26 per cent increase, worth roughly £38 billion. In all scenarios, the gains are smaller if the expected rebound in investment does not materialise.
The modelling assumes the UK applies for a new relationship in 2030 after a 2029 general election and that a deal to move closer to the EU is agreed by 2035. According to the research, about 80 per cent of the potential uplift would be delivered within 15 years, while the full benefits would not be realised until 2060.
Du says the past decade matters significantly because much of the shortfall in business investment since the Brexit referendum appears to reflect uncertainty. The paper also draws on a 2025 National Bureau of Economic Research analysis, co-authored by Stanford University professor Nicholas Bloom, which finds Brexit cut business investment by more than 12 per cent.
Investment and trade frictions shape economic impact
The analysis finds that stronger growth would come from both lower trade barriers and higher investment, with reduced customs paperwork and regulatory frictions helping goods and services trade. It also says more durable arrangements that are harder to reverse would give businesses greater certainty and support a stronger recovery in investment and productivity.The modelling includes the effects of the geopolitical shifts since 2016, including tariffs imposed by U.S. President Donald Trump and the EU’s Made in Europe agenda aimed at protecting the bloc from rising Chinese export pressure. William Bain, head of trade policy at the British Chambers of Commerce, says the research underlines the trade-offs involved on tariffs and regulatory alignment with the EU.
Prime Minister Andy Burnham is due to discuss options for a closer relationship with the EU after a summit in Brussels on Friday that is set to mark an initial reset in post-Brexit ties. He has said leaving the EU has not worked for the country and is expected to sign three more limited deals on food and drink border checks, carbon pricing and a youth experience scheme for 18 to 30-year-olds.
The UK government estimates those deals would deliver up to a 0.4 per cent GDP uplift, far below the gains modelled under deeper forms of integration. The Office for Budget Responsibility estimates Brexit has caused a 4 per cent long-run hit to UK GDP, while other studies put the loss at 6 per cent to 8 per cent.
We recently reported on the UK growth debate warning that renewed focus on EU ties could crowd out domestic reforms.