U.S. college graduates face persistent underemployment as entry-level hiring stays weak
Recent U.S. college graduates are increasingly entering jobs that do not require a degree, even as unemployment among new degree holders has cooled in recent months. Half of the class of 2025 is underemployed 12 months after graduation, well above the 2017 to 2019 average of 39%, highlighting continued pressure in the entry-level labor market.
Highlights
- Indeed data reveals the share of bachelor's holders in jobs not requiring a degree has jumped as entry-level postings decline and competition rises.
- Economists warn 73% of graduates who start underemployed remain so a decade later, with lasting impacts on wages and career progression.
- Bureau of Labor Statistics cites a $37,310 average wage for retail salespersons versus $69,770 overall, while entry-level software engineers earn about $82,000.
Indeed data highlights weak entry-level demand
As reported by Business Insider, data from job-search platform Indeed shows the share of bachelor's degree holders working in roles that do not require a college degree has risen sharply in recent years. The pattern reflects a labor market in which hiring remains limited and employers favor candidates who can contribute immediately.Indeed economist Sneha Puri says new graduates are being hit hardest because entry-level postings have declined while drawing far more applications than mid- and senior-level roles. She says hiring demand is being driven more by senior positions, leaving recent graduates facing heavier competition as they try to start their careers.
Puri expects underemployment to remain elevated for the class of 2026. She says the trend is likely to reverse only when employers place greater emphasis on hiring and training entry-level talent for future senior roles.
Long-term career and wage risks grow
Underemployment can serve as a short-term solution for graduates, but economists warn it can shape earnings and career progression over time. Daniel Zhao, chief economist at Glassdoor, says graduates who begin their working lives underemployed or unemployed can be pushed onto less rewarding career paths with lasting effects.Pay differences illustrate the gap. The Bureau of Labor Statistics says retail salespersons, a role with no formal educational credential requirement, earn an average annual wage of $37,310 based on the latest 2025 data, compared with an overall average of $69,770, while Indeed says the average base salary for an entry-level software engineer in the U.S. is about $82,000.
A 2024 report from the Burning Glass Institute and Strada Institute says 73% of graduates who start out underemployed remain so 10 years after finishing college. Major choice also affects outcomes, with New York Fed analysis based on Census Bureau data showing criminal justice, performing arts and fine arts among the fields with the highest underemployment rates in 2024, while nursing, aerospace engineering and civil engineering rank among the lowest.
As we previously wrote, UK youth employment plans aim to boost apprenticeships and incentives to reduce NEET insecurity.