Big Four auditors step up AI adoption as UK oversight and skills risks persist

Big Four auditors step up AI adoption as UK oversight and skills risks persist
AI reshapes Big Four audits

Audit firms are rapidly embedding AI into company reviews, reshaping how millions of transactions are screened for fraud, errors and higher-risk items. The shift is helping large networks such as KPMG and EY expand coverage and support audit quality, but it is also raising concerns about regulatory accountability, over-reliance on models and the training of junior staff.

Highlights

  • Big Four auditors like KPMG and EY are adopting AI models that analyse all annual transactions, improving anomaly detection and efficiency in audit workflows.
  • KPMG was fined £21mn in 2023 for Carillion audit failings, spurring investment in proprietary cloud platforms while regulatory scrutiny of AI reliability and transparency persists.
  • AI adoption raises risks of overreliance and deskilling, with firms and the Financial Reporting Council emphasizing audit quality despite cost-cutting pressures and limits on monetizing AI-generated insights.

AI tools reshape audit workflows

As reported by Financial Times, the biggest change in audit work is that AI models can scan all of a company’s annual transactions rather than leaving auditors to test only a limited sample. That allows firms to use AI agents to flag anomalies, review some junior-level work and identify cases that need closer human attention.

KPMG and EY are among the firms advancing the technology in the UK and globally. Catherine Burnet, KPMG’s UK head of audit, says technology is making the role of auditors more interesting, while Matthew Campbell, KPMG’s chief technology officer for UK audit, compares the shift to filtering an entire river rather than collecting a bucket of water for sampling.

The appeal is clear for firms handling vast volumes of corporate data. EY employs 85,000 auditors globally yet carries out nearly twice as many company audits each year, making automation attractive as a way to prevent teams from becoming overwhelmed.

Regulatory and workforce pressures remain

UK audit firms are still under pressure to improve standards after a series of failures, including the 2018 collapse of Carillion. KPMG was fined £21mn in 2023 over its Carillion audit failings, and both KPMG and EY now use their own cloud platforms to make audits more thorough.

Even so, AI does not remove responsibility from firms signing audit opinions. Auditors must still explain their reasoning and justify the action taken on each transaction or asset value reviewed, which limits how far they can rely on opaque systems.

The article points to broader risks from excessive trust in technology, including the chance that AI systems miss novel problems or produce false negatives. It also highlights the possibility of deskilling if basic tasks traditionally handled by junior auditors are shifted to agents, although EY says its approach is to use AI to support auditors rather than replace them.

The Financial Reporting Council and major firms say they want AI to improve audit quality rather than simply cut jobs or fees. Still, commercial pressure remains, with KPMG having pressed its own auditor, UK Grant Thornton, to pass on savings from AI adoption, while regulatory limits on non-audit services restrict how far firms can turn AI-generated insights into new consulting revenue.

Our earlier article on Christine Lagarde’s warning about Europe’s AI dependence explained that growing reliance on imported AI systems could leave the region exposed if access is restricted or commercial terms change, with consequences across sectors. We also noted her call for Europe to expand domestic computing and data-centre capacity and develop capable AI models on European infrastructure, while watching for spillover risks in funding markets and pension exposure.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.