Hlib Chabaniuk

McDonald’s expands AI pricing across U.S. stores, raising franchise and antitrust risks

McDonald’s expands AI pricing across U.S. stores, raising franchise and antitrust risks
McDonald's AI pricing risks

McDonald’s is deepening its use of artificial intelligence to shape menu prices across the U.S. and some international markets as it tries to balance affordability with profit growth. The system analyzes millions of daily transactions at nearly 14,000 restaurants and is creating tensions with franchisees over pricing control and legal exposure.

Highlights

  • McDonald’s expanded its AI-driven pricing tool nationwide, pressuring franchisees to align prices with machine-learning recommendations factoring in sales data and local competitor pricing.
  • Increased use of AI pricing draws antitrust scrutiny in the U.S., though legal experts note courts often side with brands on franchise pricing authority and McDonald’s denies any anti-competitive conduct.
  • Despite AI pricing aiming to boost traffic and value perception, Placer.ai reports McDonald’s U.S. foot traffic has declined year over year every month since March, intensifying operational pressures.

AI pricing system and franchise pressure

As first reported by Reuters, McDonald’s uses a machine-learning pricing engine that processes data from millions of daily sales to generate what it calls the optimal price for each menu item at each restaurant. Screenshots reviewed in August show the system assesses factors including customer willingness to pay in a given area and also displays public menu prices from nearby rivals such as Wendy’s and Burger King.

The company says franchisees remain free to set their own prices, but several store owners told Reuters they face pressure to follow the tool’s recommendations. An internal communication reviewed by Reuters shows McDonald’s in January began requiring franchisees to be constructively engaging with approved pricing consultants and tools under new business standards, while a June document shows the company tracks how closely owners follow those recommendations.

A September check of prices on McDonald’s mobile app showed notable differences between nearby restaurants. In Fresno, California, one company-run outlet listed a Big Mac at $5.69, while another company-run store two miles away priced it at $6.89, although Reuters could not confirm whether the gap resulted from the pricing engine or other factors.

McDonald’s says the portal is a tool rather than a mandate and argues that costs and market conditions can vary even between stores a few miles apart. The company told Reuters its reporting was speculative and uninformed, while adding that the recommendations are intended to help franchisees deliver value and make informed business decisions.

Regulatory scrutiny and business impact

McDonald’s wider use of AI in pricing comes as regulators and courts in the U.S. examine whether algorithmic pricing can facilitate unlawful coordination among competitors. Legal terms for the company’s pricing portal warn franchisees that they may be competitors of one another and must comply fully with antitrust and competition laws, a point some legal experts say reflects the sensitivity of the issue.

William Kovacic, director of the competition law center at George Washington University and a former Federal Trade Commission commissioner, said that language acknowledges a potential problem amid broader regulatory scrutiny. Other experts told Reuters the legal risk may still be limited because courts have often given brands broad authority over franchise pricing practices, and McDonald’s says its antitrust guidance is not evidence of anti-competitive conduct.

The strategy also exposes a commercial conflict between corporate headquarters and franchisees. McDonald’s earns most of its money by taking a percentage of franchisees’ total revenue, giving it an incentive to use lower prices to drive traffic, while operators are more motivated to lift menu prices to offset higher labor, rent and other expenses, which the National Restaurant Association estimates are up 36% since 2019.

Some franchisees say the engine encouraged steep increases during and after the pandemic but has more recently pushed restraint, and in some cases lower prices, to support value offerings. Even so, Placer.ai estimates U.S. foot traffic at McDonald’s has fallen year over year in every complete month since March, underscoring the pressure on the chain as it leans further into AI-led pricing.

Our earlier article covered the Malaysian High Court’s decision to grant a stay on the RM367 million penalty imposed by the Malaysia Competition Commission on four major animal feed producers over alleged price-fixing, pending judicial review. We noted that the outcome could materially shape corporate competition-compliance expectations and the financial risk companies face when regulators pursue enforcement actions for pricing conduct.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.