European governments are facing renewed scrutiny over how unanimity on sanctions is limiting the bloc's foreign policy leverage. France's recent threat to block the renewal of Russia sanctions highlights how national bargaining is undermining the EU's strategic credibility.
Highlights
- France's demand to remove Alisher Usmanov from the EU sanctions list delayed their renewal, exposing vulnerabilities from the bloc's unanimity requirement.
- Azerbaijan and Luxembourg leveraged the veto process for national interests, prompting a compromise to extend remaining sanctions for three years instead of six months.
- Calls to adopt qualified majority voting on sanctions are growing, as current unanimity facilitates external influence and undermines the EU's strategic autonomy and coordination.
France dispute exposes sanctions weakness
As reported by Financial Times, France last month held up the six-month renewal of sanctions on individuals and companies linked to Russian President Vladimir Putin's regime, threatening to let the measures lapse unless billionaire Alisher Usmanov was removed from the list.The episode reflects the EU's unanimity requirement on sanctions, which gives each member state veto power. According to the account, Azerbaijan tied the demand to the release of French citizens detained there, and Luxembourg then sought the removal of another oligarch from the sanctions list.
The compromise ultimately extends the remaining sanctions for three years rather than six months. Baku then releases one French prisoner, reducing the chance of an immediate repeat but raising broader concerns over how easily outside states can influence EU decision-making.
Pressure grows for majority voting
Other member states have also used the process for national advantage, including Greece over Russian gas shipping and Hungary through repeated veto threats. But France's role carries particular weight because it is a founding EU member and President Emmanuel Macron has strongly promoted the idea of European strategic autonomy.The broader concern is that the bloc is losing geopolitical influence by allowing sanctions decisions to become bargaining chips. A more strategic policy would link sanctions more clearly to foreign policy demands and would require the EU to threaten or ease restrictions in a more coordinated and credible way.
That objective remains difficult while all 27 member states can block action. The article argues that shifting sanctions policy to qualified majority voting, as already provided for in EU treaties, is the best-known route to stronger coordination, even though such a change would itself require unanimity and currently faces weak political support.
Supporters of reform say majority voting would not automatically produce a tougher policy, given the EU's cautious use of other trade and anti-coercion tools against the U.S. and China. Still, they see it as a necessary step if the bloc wants to avoid being divided by outside powers and preserve its collective economic and strategic interests.
Our earlier article on Ukraine’s push for tougher sanctions on satellite and communications technology explained Kyiv’s concerns that Russia, with external support, is developing the Rassvet network as an alternative to Starlink. We noted that Ukrainian officials argue these capabilities could improve Russia’s drone coordination and strike precision, and they urged broader restrictions on companies and components linked to the project.