KBRA affirms First Interstate BancSystem ratings with stable outlook
First Interstate BancSystem retains its existing KBRA credit ratings as the lender continues to improve profitability and stabilize asset quality after its post-acquisition credit issues. The Billings, Montana-based bank group also keeps a Stable outlook across all long-term ratings, reflecting solid capital, funding and liquidity despite returns that still trail some peers.
Highlights
- KBRA affirmed all major ratings for First Interstate BancSystem and subsidiary First Interstate Bank, maintaining a stable outlook on strong capital and core deposit franchise.
- Core return on assets neared 1.1% and net interest margin reached 3.57% in Q3 2026, while $3.3 billion in low-yield assets are expected to reprice by 2027.
- Common equity tier 1 capital rose to 14.4% with $347 million in share repurchases since 2025, but tangible common equity remains pressured by unrealized portfolio losses.
Rating action and financial profile
As reported by Kroll Bond Rating Agency, KBRA affirmed the senior unsecured debt rating of BBB+, the subordinated debt rating of BBB and the short-term debt rating of K2 for First Interstate BancSystem, while affirming an A- deposit and senior unsecured debt rating, a BBB+ subordinated debt rating and K2 short-term deposit and debt ratings for subsidiary First Interstate Bank.The agency says the ratings are supported by a strong core deposit franchise, conservative balance sheet construction, robust regulatory capital levels and historically favorable credit performance. KBRA also points to management's progress in repositioning the balance sheet, strengthening credit administration and improving the operating model, though it notes recent profitability remains weaker than peers and nonperforming assets are still somewhat elevated.
Operating performance is improving, with core return on assets nearing 1.1% in the first nine months of 2026 and net interest margin expanding for a tenth straight quarter to 3.57% in the third quarter of 2026. KBRA says about $3.3 billion of earning assets with below-market yields are expected to reprice or generate cash flows through 2027, which should support earnings, although noncore loan runoff, a securities-heavy asset mix and modest balance sheet growth may limit net interest income expansion.
Capital strength and credit risks
The bank's credit profile has also shown signs of stabilization through the first nine months of 2026 after some negative migration tied to loans acquired in First Interstate's 2022 purchase of Great Western Bancorp. Criticized loans fell about 19% from a year earlier to 6.7% of loans at the end of the third quarter of 2026, while nonperforming assets remained elevated at about 1.1% of loans.KBRA says management's focus on core markets and balance sheet de-risking has strengthened capital ratios and supported a more aggressive share buyback program in 2025 and 2026. Common equity tier 1 capital reached 14.4% in the third quarter of 2026, and the company has repurchased $347 million of shares since 2025, although tangible common equity remains relatively low because of unrealized losses in the investment portfolio.
Funding and liquidity remain key strengths, according to KBRA, with core deposits accounting for 95% of total funding sources at the end of the third quarter of 2026 and a conservative 65% loan-to-deposit ratio. The agency says positive rating momentum would require sustained profitability gains alongside strong asset quality and conservative capital management, while weaker credit quality, reduced liquidity or more aggressive capital deployment could pressure the ratings.
As we noted earlier, Fitch affirmed Capital Farm Credit's BBB rating with a Stable Outlook, citing resilient asset quality.