Life insurers lag in private markets risk assessment as allocations expand
Growing exposure to private markets is outpacing life insurers' ability to evaluate the risks tied to those assets. The gap is particularly visible in credit risk assessment, valuation and capital allocation, raising questions about how the sector manages more complex investments.
Highlights
- Life insurers' risk assessment capabilities in private markets lag banks significantly, particularly in credit risk, valuation, and capital allocation, as allocations rise.
- Insurers and asset managers increasingly favor infrastructure investments related to AI demand, such as data center power, over higher-risk direct technology bets.
- L&G's Nicholas Bamber urges greater regulatory transparency on rating agencies amid heightened insurer participation in private credit and private market investments.
Risk capabilities trail private market expansion
As reported by Bloomberg, Lukas Ziewer, a researcher and former chief risk officer at Athora, says life insurers have not developed the same level of expertise as banks in analyzing private market investments. He says the shortfall versus the pace of deployment is "fairly significant" in areas including credit risk assessment, valuation and capital allocation.The comments point to a structural challenge for insurers as they increase exposure to less liquid and harder-to-value assets. Compared with banks, life insurers are still building the internal skills needed to judge complex private market risks and to align those assessments with capital decisions.
Private credit and infrastructure draw focus
Deborah Shire of Axa IM says investment in the power needed for data centers offers a less risky way to benefit from the artificial intelligence boom, because the downside is more limited. Her remarks suggest insurers and asset managers are looking for infrastructure-linked opportunities tied to AI demand rather than relying on higher-risk direct bets.Nicholas Bamber, global head of private credit at L&G's asset management business, says regulators should be far more public about their views on rating agencies. That stance adds to a broader debate over transparency and oversight as insurers deepen their participation in private credit and other private market segments.
This adds to earlier discussion around middle-market credit stress, as KBRA flagged rising defaults and surveillance downgrades in direct lending.