ICE Climate research finds avoided emissions metric exposes gap in corporate climate disclosures
Corporate climate reporting often tracks companies' own emissions and reduction targets, but it does not show how much decarbonization their products enable across the wider economy. ICE Climate says its analysis of nearly 600 companies indicates avoided emissions should be treated as a separate metric when investors assess corporate climate impact.
Highlights
- ICE Climate research of nearly 600 companies found no statistically significant link between standard disclosure measures and estimated avoided emissions intensity.
- Green revenue share often correlates with avoided emissions intensity, making it a more reliable indicator of positive climate impact than traditional disclosure metrics, including Scope 1-3 emissions.
- ICE Climate asserts that relying solely on footprint reporting and decarbonization targets risks overlooking real-world decarbonization enabled by products, advocating independent avoided emissions reporting.
Research methodology and main findings
As reported by ICE, the study examines avoided emissions across nearly 600 companies using factors from the Avoided Emissions Platform, or AEP, and finds almost no statistical relationship between standard disclosure measures and estimated avoided emissions intensity.ICE Climate models avoided emissions as Weighted Average Avoided Carbon Intensity, or WAACI, measured in tCO2e per U.S.$1 million of revenue, to compare companies of different sizes on a like-for-like basis. The dataset combines AEP factors with cross-industry production data to estimate how products and technologies such as solar power and batteries reduce emissions outside their own lifecycle or value chain.
The research tests avoided emissions against disclosure quality, reported and modelled Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions, Science Based Targets initiative temperature scores, greenhouse gas reduction targets and green revenue data. It says disclosure quality, target-setting and a company's own emissions intensity show no statistically significant link with avoided emissions intensity across the sample, even after controls for sector, region and company size.
ICE Climate also says some of the highest-emitting companies in the sample, including large power utilities, rank among the strongest avoided-emissions performers. By contrast, green revenue share is often correlated with avoided emissions intensity, making it a relatively more reliable signal of positive climate impact than traditional disclosure metrics alone.
Implications for investors and climate assessment
The findings suggest investors and other market participants may miss an important dimension of corporate climate performance if they rely only on footprint reporting and decarbonization commitments. In ICE Climate's framework, a company's climate profile has three separate dimensions: the quality of its emissions disclosure, the credibility of its reduction pathway and the broader emissions cuts enabled by its products.Avoided emissions remains outside the Greenhouse Gas Protocol and is less widely recognized than Scope-based reporting, but ICE Climate argues that gap leaves standard frameworks incomplete. The company says avoided emissions provides both evidence of estimated real-world decarbonization contribution and an indicator of growth potential as demand shifts toward low-carbon solutions.
For climate-related products and technologies, the research points to a need for an additional yardstick rather than a replacement for existing disclosures. ICE Climate says avoided emissions should be measured and reported independently because traditional reporting does not capture the full extent of companies' outward contribution to economy-wide decarbonization.
Earlier, we looked at the AIIB-UN cooperation framework aimed at scaling climate finance and bankable sustainable infrastructure in developing economies.