Semantan Estate sues government over Duta land sale, response due by Jan 4

Semantan Estate sues government over Duta land sale, response due by Jan 4
Semantan Estate sues government

Court proceedings over the claim to 263.272 acres of Duta land in Kuala Lumpur have moved to the defence stage, with the federal government ordered to file its response. The latest action comes as Semantan Estate (1952) Sdn Bhd, which is undergoing voluntary liquidation, continues several other lawsuits concerning sale proceeds, compensation and mesne profits.

Highlights

  • The High Court ordered the federal government to file its defence by Jan 4, 2025, in response to Semantan Estate's suit concerning Duta land.
  • Semantan Estate is seeking a declaration that the government is a trustee and claiming rights to the sale proceeds or compensation under Article 13 of the Federal Constitution.
  • The latest suit is proceeding alongside two other cases: a decision is pending in the mesne profits claim, while the hearing on compensation assessed at 1956 rates is ongoing.

This article was translated from the original. Read the original version by our correspondent here.

Court timetable for latest suit

As reported by The Edge Malaysia, the High Court on Tuesday ordered the federal government to file its defence by Jan 4 next year in response to the latest suit filed last month by Semantan Estate (1952) Sdn Bhd.

Judge Datuk Anand Ponnudurai also ordered Semantan Estate to file its reply by Feb 12 and set Feb 16 for the next case management hearing. The government was represented by senior federal counsel Nurhafizza Azizan and Shazreen Nadia Zulkipli, along with federal counsel Nuur Zul Izzati Zulkipli, while Semantan Estate was represented by AG Kalidas and Choo Shi Jin of Messrs AG Kalidas Doris & Nada.

In its writ and statement of claim, the company is seeking a declaration that the government holds the prime land as trustee on its behalf. It is also seeking a court order requiring the government to sell or agree to sell the land within a specified period, and directing the Federal Lands Commissioner, as registered owner, and the other defendants to sign the necessary documents to complete the sale without re-registering the land in Semantan Estate's name.

The company is also seeking recognition of its entitlement to the sale proceeds, less any amounts credited through other proceedings. Alternatively, Semantan Estate is seeking equitable compensation or other relief to enforce rights arising from the government's position as trustee, including compensation under Article 13 of the Federal Constitution, which protects property rights.

Litigation implications for the asset and compensation claims

The latest suit names six defendants: the Government of Malaysia, the Federal Lands Commissioner, the Federal Territories Minister, the Director General of the Department of Lands and Mines, the Director of the Federal Territories Department of Lands and Mines, and the Minister of Natural Resources and Environmental Sustainability.

The case is proceeding alongside two other ongoing proceedings. The first is a claim for mesne profits against the government, the hearing for which has concluded and which is now awaiting a decision from Judge Datuk Ahmad Shahrir Mohd Salleh, who is now a Court of Appeal judge.

The second is the assessment of compensation payable to the company at 1956 rates, as directed by the Court of Appeal last year. The hearing is ongoing before Judge Roslan Mat Nor. The combination of these legal actions highlights the protracted dispute over the economic value of Duta land and how the benefits should be returned to Semantan Estate as the party claiming rights to the asset.

In our earlier report on the government's efforts to recover funds from the National Feedlot (NFC) project, the Ministry of Finance said RM33.74 million was still being claimed, although some assets and RM86.9 million had already been recovered. The article also discussed the High Court ruling recognising the government's rights to seized funds and several properties, while forfeiture proceedings for the remaining assets are ongoing.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.