Coles appeals ACCC block on Kalgoorlie supermarket expansion
A tribunal decision on Coles' plan to add a supermarket and liquor store in Kalgoorlie-Boulder is now pending after hearings in Melbourne conclude this week. The case is testing how Australia's competition rules apply in remote regional markets, where residents, regulators and existing operators are sharply divided over the effect of new retail investment.
Highlights
- Coles has appealed the ACCC's July block of its Kalgoorlie expansion, with the Australian Competition Tribunal concluding eight days of hearings Thursday and reserving its decision for up to 90 days.
- The ACCC argues a new Coles would likely reduce competition and threaten independents like O'Connor Fresh IGA, while Coles warns such rulings could deter regional capital investment.
- The tribunal's ruling is expected to set a precedent for future supermarket and liquor expansion decisions in remote Australian cities, drawing significant investor attention.
Tribunal review of contested Kalgoorlie project
As reported by ABC News, Coles is appealing the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission's July decision to block the proposed development under the regulator's new powers. The Australian Competition Tribunal concludes eight days of hearings on Thursday and the three-member panel reserves its decision, which must be made within 90 days.The ACCC argues the expansion could cause a substantial lessening of competition in the local market, with concerns centred on smaller independent rivals including O'Connor Fresh IGA. ACCC lawyer Declan Roche SC tells the tribunal that an additional Coles outlet would threaten the viability of existing competitors in Kalgoorlie-Boulder.
Coles rejects that view and says the ruling could discourage future capital deployment in the region. Its lawyer, John Sheahan KC, argues investors may hesitate to enter markets where expansion faces regulatory resistance, adding that Coles previously operated two stores in the area from 1986 to 2021.
Regional investment concerns and local divide
Supporters of the proposal say a new supermarket would increase consumer choice in Australia's largest outback city and could support local development. Former Kalgoorlie-Boulder deputy mayor Doug Daws is among residents backing the project, saying new spending in the city and another supermarket would benefit the community.The dispute also exposes a broader split over how competition should be assessed in smaller regional centres. While some locals want another major operator to challenge existing stores, others fear the loss of independent businesses if a new Coles site proceeds.
Tribunal president Justice Michael O'Bryan says the matter involves balancing added consumer choice against the risk of weaker competition in the local grocery market. The outcome is being closely watched for what it may signal about future supermarket and liquor investment in remote Australian communities.
We have also discussed the broader context around Australia’s AI competition review as regulators weigh how AI agent shopping could affect pricing and market conduct.