Berkshire Hathaway faces valuation pressure after Argus cuts rating
Berkshire Hathaway's strong 2026 run as an alternative to artificial intelligence-linked stocks is prompting fresh scrutiny of its valuation. The shares have climbed above Argus Research's $550 price target, leading the firm to argue the stock is now fully valued despite continued support from buybacks and defensive portfolio holdings.
Highlights
- Berkshire Hathaway was downgraded to hold from buy by Argus after rising above its $550 price target, closing Thursday at $572.04.
- Berkshire trades at 25 times Argus's 2027 operating earnings estimate with a 1.60 price-to-book ratio, above the 1.5 times level Argus would consider for upgrading.
- Berkshire accelerated share buybacks from $235 million in March to $4.5 billion in Q2 and $9.6 billion in Q3, while shifting large holdings among Apple, Alphabet, Bending Spoons, Lennar, Delta Air Lines, Bank of America, and Kroger.
Valuation reset after rally
As reported by CNBC, Argus Research downgraded Berkshire Hathaway to hold from buy on Friday after the conglomerate's shares moved above the firm's $550 price target earlier this month. Berkshire closed Thursday at $572.04 and has gained more than 6% over the past month, helped by its own share repurchases and investor demand for stocks less exposed to the artificial intelligence trade.Argus analysts Kevin Heal and Shutaro Yasuda said Berkshire is trading at about 25 times the firm's 2027 estimate for operating earnings per share, a level they described as fully valued. They added that they would consider upgrading the stock back to buy if it fell below 1.5 times book value, compared with its current price-to-book ratio of 1.60, according to FactSet data.
Berkshire resumed buybacks in March for the first time since 2024, repurchasing $235 million of its own stock. That pace then accelerated to $4.5 billion in the second quarter and $9.6 billion in the third quarter.
Portfolio positioning supports defensive appeal
Berkshire's holdings in traditional value names including Coca-Cola, Chevron, American Express and Bank of America are also supporting its appeal as sentiment weakens around AI-linked shares. That shift in market tone became more visible on Thursday, when stocks sold off even after Anthropic's strong market debut in a historic IPO that valued the AI company at about $2 trillion.Argus also noted that Berkshire's portfolio still includes major technology exposure. Apple remains its largest equity holding after the company first invested in the iPhone maker in early 2016, although Chief Executive Greg Abel has more recently reduced that position.
Berkshire started buying Alphabet in 2025 under Warren Buffett's guidance and sharply expanded those purchases in 2026. More recently, it began investing in Italian software company Bending Spoons at the end of the second quarter and added to that position in the September quarter, while also nearly doubling its stake in homebuilder Lennar and increasing its holding in Delta Air Lines as it cut positions in Bank of America and Kroger.
In a previous article, we explained how a defensive stocks rally was lifting valuations as investors rotated out of tech.