AI shopping agents face slow Black Friday adoption as trust hurdles persist
The first holiday shopping season after consumer AI agents became widely available is testing whether bots can move from product discovery to actual purchases. Early usage remains limited, and shoppers and retailers are still weighing reliability, control and the personal nature of gift buying.
Highlights
- AI agents contributed less than 1% of retailers' web traffic during Black Friday, with Uber reporting only 500 out of 320 million weekly transactions from AI agents.
- Retailers like All Star Elite report AI agent-driven purchases just once or twice weekly, prompting investment in machine-readable data layers despite unclear agent purchasing roles.
- Major retailers are diverging on AI integration strategies, with Walmart enhancing agent experiences while Amazon blocks external bots and steers customers to Alexa, reflecting trust concerns and strategic risks.
Early adoption stays limited in holiday shopping
As first reported by Business Insider, early signs from Black Friday shopping suggest AI agents are helping some consumers search for products and deals, but they are not yet becoming a mainstream checkout tool. The article cites a Bain & Co. analysis of Similarweb data showing AI assistants account for less than 1% of retailers' web traffic, while Uber recently said only about 500 of roughly 320 million transactions in the final week of October came from AI agents.Consumer experiences remain mixed. New York therapist Dean Mandelos said Meta's Muse helped him with practical tasks including listing items on eBay and collecting contractor bids, but its holiday gift suggestions felt less attuned to the social side of shopping. He also said the agent ran into expired listings, sold-out products and blocks from large e-commerce platforms including Amazon and eBay.
Retailers are beginning to adapt even as volumes stay small. Abhishek Bora, head of growth at streetwear seller All Star Elite, said agentic traffic makes up about 1% of the company's website traffic, mostly from Meta's Muse, and the retailer is adding machine-readable data layers to help bots better interpret products and promotions. He said the business sees a Muse-driven purchase once or twice a week, but it is still unclear when agents are completing purchases themselves versus guiding shoppers to buy manually.
Trust and retailer strategy shape the next phase
Analysts and executives say the bigger barrier is trust rather than awareness. Kantar retail analyst Gina Logan said AI can play a meaningful role in Black Friday shopping, but shoppers still want control, while Zappi founder Steve Phillips said the pattern resembles the early days of online hotel booking, when consumers used the web for research before completing transactions through more familiar channels.That hesitation also reflects the risks for retailers. Logan said a poor agent-led shopping experience could damage customer relationships built over years, especially when gift purchases carry more emotional weight than routine replenishment. Walmart is rolling out tools aimed at making agentic shopping easier, while Amazon is blocking external bots and steering customers toward Alexa, showing how major retailers are taking different positions on third-party AI agents.
For many consumers, AI is proving more useful in narrowing choices than in clicking the final buy button. Amrita Bhasin, co-founder and chief executive of Sotira, said she uses ChatGPT and Gemini to find apparel and beauty products, particularly from unfamiliar brands, but still prefers to finish the transaction herself. Mandelos said he is continuing to test detailed prompts and budgets for gifts, yet for his sister's present he is still shopping the traditional way.
Earlier, we discussed AI scam sites that mimic real retailers and try to steal shoppers’ payment details around Black Friday.