UK mortgage market struggles to adapt to self-employed borrowers
Changing work patterns are leaving many UK borrowers with irregular incomes struggling to access home loans. Research indicates that self-employed applicants are especially likely to delay or abandon mortgage applications as lenders continue to rely on affordability tests geared toward salaried workers.
Highlights
- Nottingham Building Society's survey finds 27 per cent of recent homebuyers reconsidered or abandoned mortgage applications due to non-standard income, rising to 49 per cent among self-employed respondents.
- Average rates on two-year fixed-rate mortgages rose to 5.97 per cent this week from 5.88 per cent a month ago, according to Moneyfacts, amid market volatility.
- Specialist products like Skipton Building Society’s Track Record mortgage and Nottingham's Worldwide Welcome aim to improve access for renters, foreign nationals, and those with limited UK credit records.
Research highlights barriers in mortgage assessments
As reported by Financial Times, citing Nottingham Building Society, its survey of 2,000 borrowers and 500 mortgage brokers finds that the mortgage market still favours long-term salaried employees over applicants with non-standard income patterns.The research says 27 per cent of recent homebuyers have delayed, dropped out of or decided against a mortgage application because of how they earn, with that figure rising to 49 per cent among self-employed respondents. It defines non-standard borrowers as contract workers, people with income from multiple sources and those paid at irregular intervals.
Aaron Shinwell, chief lending officer at Nottingham Building Society, says self-employment, contract work, multiple income streams and career breaks are now normal for millions of people, while too much of the mortgage market still treats those circumstances as unusual. The report adds that lenders have failed to keep pace with shifts in work over the past 30 years, including the growth of the gig economy, portfolio careers and side hustles.
People with thin credit records, returning expats without evidence of a UK credit history, and borrowers whose finances have been disrupted by bereavement or illness also face difficulties, the report says. It adds that unsuccessful applicants often assume they will be rejected by all lenders, even though affordability criteria vary across the market.
Competitive pressures and wider market impact
Mortgage access issues are emerging as borrowers also face higher borrowing costs. According to Moneyfacts, average rates on two-year fixed-rate mortgages have climbed to 5.97 per cent this week from 5.88 per cent four weeks ago, as inflation and energy costs unsettle markets.The report says building societies are often better placed than high street banks to assess unusual cases individually, while larger retail banks more commonly rely on automated tools for parts of the mortgage process. It calls for greater consistency across the market, including more standardised treatment of complex incomes, greater use of rental payment records in affordability checks and recognition of overseas credit histories.
Examples of specialist products already exist. Skipton Building Society offers its Track Record mortgage, which uses 12 consecutive months of rent payments as evidence of affordability for loans with loan-to-value ratios of up to 100 per cent, while Nottingham offers its Worldwide Welcome product for foreign nationals and returning expats with limited credit records or hard-to-evidence financial profiles.
David Hollingworth, director at broker L&C Mortgages, agrees that some borrowers give up too quickly after adverse decisions, but says differences between lenders reflect healthy competition. The survey also finds that 68 per cent of brokers believe non-standard borrowers are likely to become the norm in coming years, while two-thirds of respondents say people with variable or irregular incomes are viewed as higher risk and find it harder to secure a home loan.
In our earlier article, we looked at how Bank Negara Malaysia’s updated policy guidance was read by markets as leaving more room for interest-rate adjustments amid inflation risks tied to high energy prices and Middle East tensions. We also noted how these expectations fed into market pricing, alongside commentary on the ringgit’s relative stability and increased bond-yield volatility as investors tracked global developments.