Malaysian retailers urge fair competition framework for foreign e-commerce
Retailers in Malaysia are increasing pressure on the government as competition from foreign e-commerce platforms is seen as undermining the position of domestic businesses. Their appeal to the Ministry of Finance includes comprehensive policy proposals that the industry says are needed to protect SMEs, jobs and compliance with local regulations.
Highlights
- MRCA proposes requiring foreign e-commerce platforms to incorporate locally, maintain a physical office and have minimum paid-up capital of RM10 million in Malaysia.
- MRCA wants the 10% sales tax on low-value goods to remain in place and a fixed import duty of RM10 for each category of imported items to be introduced.
- MRCA warns that 1.29 million local SMEs are at risk from 16.8 million active merchants on foreign platforms, and that a lack of regulation could lead to systemic SME closures and job losses.
This article was translated from the original. Read the original version by our correspondent here.
Policy proposals to regulate foreign platforms
As reported by The Edge Malaysia, the Malaysia Retail Chain Association, or MRCA, has submitted a set of policy proposals to the Ministry of Finance to establish a fairer competitive framework for foreign e-commerce platforms operating in the country.In its latest statement, MRCA said it remains pro-business and welcomes international companies that stimulate job creation and technological innovation. However, the association stressed that every entity doing business in Malaysia must comply with the country's laws, tax obligations and product safety standards.
MRCA said significant market gaps are creating an uneven playing field, with foreign platforms selling imported goods at aggressively low prices while local retailers continue to bear the costs of rent, wages, Employees Provident Fund contributions, Social Security Organisation contributions, sales and service tax, and certification.
Key proposals include requiring foreign platforms to incorporate locally, maintain a physical office and have minimum paid-up capital of RM10 million, while making them ineligible for preferential SME tax rates. MRCA also proposed requiring at least one foreign director, verifying product compliance—including Sirim and Ministry of Health certification—and localizing user data on servers physically located in Malaysia.
The association also wants a minimum quota for local merchant participation, as well as a role for platforms as global trade bridges to help Malaysian companies export their products. For foreign merchants and retailers, MRCA proposed extending similar requirements, including minimum paid-up capital of RM1 million and the appointment of a foreign director.
In addition, MRCA's third proposal is to retain the 10% sales tax on low-value goods while adding a fixed import duty of RM10 for each category of item imported under the regime. The fourth proposal is to establish a cross-agency National Council for Fair E-Commerce Competition to publish annual reports tracking platform sales, SME participation and product violation rates.
Risks to SMEs and the retail sector
MRCA warned that the domestic market is facing a four-stage erosion, beginning with the influx of cheap imports, followed by margin pressure, the closure of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises alongside widespread job losses, and ultimately foreign dominance over access to the market and the country's consumer data.The association said around 1.29 million SMEs in Malaysia are now facing a foreign-platform ecosystem with 16.8 million active merchants—more than 15 times the country's entire SME population. According to MRCA, without stricter regulation, unchecked cross-border imports will lead to systemic SME closures, job losses and the hollowing out of the local retail sector.
To strengthen its case, MRCA cited several international examples, including a €200 million penalty imposed by the European Union on a non-compliant platform, the separation of social commerce in Indonesia alongside a U.S.$100 price floor, and China's stance against predatory below-cost dumping. The association said its proposals offer the Ministry of Finance and key regulators a balanced action plan based on global benchmarks.
In our earlier coverage of the coordination of enforcement measures for the entry of products and entities from abroad, we reported that the government had established an inter-ministerial working committee to examine enforcement measures and the legal framework, including the drafting of an e-Commerce Bill. The article also discussed efforts to strengthen the digital trade ecosystem by promoting local products, such as standardizing the “Jom Beli Produk Malaysia” logo, and funding the Jom Malaysia program to help SMEs enter digital platforms and international markets.