U.S. Senate Democrats urge CFTC to withdraw prediction markets order

U.S. Senate Democrats urge CFTC to withdraw prediction markets order
Senate vs. CFTC order

Political pressure on the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission is rising as court fights over prediction markets and state gambling laws intensify. Senate Democrats say the agency's demand that exchanges stop geofencing conflicts with active court orders in several states and tribal areas.

Highlights

  • U.S. Senate Democrats urged the CFTC to withdraw its directive requiring regulated prediction markets to end state-by-state geofencing and operate in all 50 states.
  • Judicial rulings in Michigan, Nevada, Washington, and parts of California mandate geofencing or ban certain contracts, directly conflicting with the CFTC's federal preemption stance.
  • Louisiana, via temporary restraining order, and Arkansas with a November 4 lawsuit, target Kalshi and others as illegal gambling operations, while the CFTC continues related litigation across a dozen states.

Regulatory clash over geofencing order

As reported by CoinDesk, several U.S. Senate Democrats are urging the CFTC to reverse a recent directive telling regulated prediction market platforms to end state-by-state geofencing and maintain operations across all 50 states. In a letter sent Monday, the lawmakers argue that the order puts exchanges at odds with court rulings that have already required companies including Kalshi to halt certain contracts in specific jurisdictions.

The dispute centers on the CFTC's position that designated contract markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket fall under federal derivatives law, which Chairman Mike Selig says preempts state efforts to enforce gambling restrictions. Earlier this month, the agency told platforms they had 30 days either to remove state-level access restrictions or explain why they could not do so.

Democrats on the Senate Agriculture Committee say that approach directly conflicts with ongoing litigation and existing judicial orders. They point to rulings in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as on the land of two California tribes, where courts have required geofencing or ordered certain prediction contracts to stop trading.

Legal and political stakes widen

Louisiana is the latest jurisdiction pressing for limits on prediction markets after a judge cleared the way for state officials to prohibit such contracts there. A temporary restraining order in the state targets Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Coinbase, Gemini, Crypto.com and others, while the CFTC has separately sued to block that action and some companies, including Crypto.com, have moved to join the federal case.

The agency is also suing Arkansas, adding it to roughly a dozen states where it is seeking to defend its authority over prediction markets. Arkansas separately sued Kalshi on Nov. 4, alleging the company is operating an illegal gambling business.

The fight is unfolding as the CFTC remains short-handed under Selig, its only sitting commissioner, despite the agency being structured for five members. The White House has nominated Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland to join the commission, and the Senate Agriculture Committee is set to hold a confirmation hearing for them on Tuesday.

We have also discussed the broader context around Germany crypto freeze bill expanding customs powers to temporarily immobilize high-value assets without charges.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.