Kalshi seeks to block New York restraining order threat to exchange operations
A new court setback is increasing pressure on Kalshi as New York moves closer to seeking an order that could disrupt the prediction market operator's business. The dispute is testing whether states can curb federally regulated event contracts, a question that is becoming central to the wider U.S. prediction markets industry.
Highlights
- A U.S. District Court ruled the Kalshi dispute belongs in state court, raising immediate legal risk as New York seeks a restraining order to halt its operations.
- The CFTC argued halting Kalshi's activities in New York would effectively shut down the exchange due to its headquarters and all operations originating from the state.
- Conflicting federal court rulings on CFTC versus state authority over prediction markets heighten legal uncertainty and raise the likelihood of U.S. Supreme Court review.
Legal fight intensifies in New York
As first reported by CoinDesk, Kalshi is trying to secure a chance to argue against a proposed temporary restraining order after a federal judge sent the case back to the Supreme Court of New York, where state authorities are seeking to halt the company's event contracts.The company had tried to keep the matter in federal court after New York Attorney General Letitia James previously moved against its operations. But the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York ruled on Thursday that the dispute belongs in state court, increasing the immediate legal risk for the exchange.
An assistant attorney general for New York filed a proposed motion for a temporary restraining order on Friday. A filing by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission the same day argued that forcing Kalshi to stop operating in New York would effectively require it to cease all operations because the company is headquartered there and all of its business originates from the state.
Kalshi argues that such a ban would place it in conflict with federal oversight because the CFTC has directed exchanges like it to continue operating nationwide without state-by-state limits. However, a federal judge later denied the CFTC's motion in a telephone hearing on Friday, according to attorney Daniel Wallach's social media post.
Kalshi spokeswoman Elisabeth Diana said the company has operated lawfully since receiving certification as a federally regulated exchange under the Biden administration and wants to work with New York officials on a resolution that protects its 1.2 million users in the state.
Wider regulatory stakes for prediction markets
New York is among several U.S. states that contend prediction market contracts tied to sports events and political campaigns amount to gambling and should fall under state gaming laws. In July, the state sued Kalshi and accused it of running an illegal gambling operation, while James said prediction markets such as Kalshi are gambling platforms despite how they are labeled.Before that lawsuit, the New York Gambling Commission had already sought to stop the business, prompting Kalshi to respond with its own lawsuit. The company has also halted operations in several states in response to court orders, even as the CFTC recently directed the industry to keep operating nationwide.
The case is unfolding as courts issue conflicting rulings on whether the CFTC has exclusive authority over prediction markets or whether states can also intervene. This week, a third federal appellate court ruled against Kalshi's position, adding to legal uncertainty that is increasing the likelihood of eventual review by the U.S. Supreme Court.
We have also analyzed the proposed DOJ whistleblower program aimed at rooting out insider trading and fraud on prediction markets.