ACE Holdings fails to overturn SC fine in judicial review in Malaysia
The High Court in Kuala Lumpur dismissed ACE Holdings Bhd's judicial review application against the Securities Commission Malaysia's decision to impose a RM400,000 fine and reprimand on the company. The ruling reinforces the regulator's administrative powers under the Capital Markets and Services Act in a case involving alleged false or misleading statements made to the SC.
Highlights
- The High Court dismissed ACE Holdings' judicial review, ruling that the SC acted within its jurisdiction under Section 354(1)(a) of the CMSA and Section 152(2)(a) of the SCMA.
- ACE Holdings was ordered to pay RM10,000 in costs to the Securities Commission after being found to have made false or misleading statements in private placement documents from 2015 and 2018.
- The dispute is linked to the takeover of Apex Equity Holdings and ACE Holdings' role as controller, with the SC alleging securities law breaches by Apex Securities and ACE.
This article was translated from the original. Read the original version by our correspondent here.
Court ruling and legal basis
As reported by The Edge Malaysia, Judge Norliza Othman dismissed ACE Holdings' application after the court rejected the company's argument that the SC had acted ultra vires when exercising its administrative powers under Section 354(1)(a) of the Capital Markets and Services Act over alleged breaches of the Securities Commission Malaysia Act 1993.Norliza said the court found that the plain reading of Section 354(1)(a) of the CMSA was clear, and that the SC had acted within its jurisdiction because the provision excludes only “Part V and Part 2 of Part VI of the CMSA”, which govern market misconduct, prohibited conduct, and the regulatory framework for takeovers, mergers and compulsory acquisitions. The court also stated that the exclusion does not cover “any securities law” as defined under Section 2 of the SCMA.
The court also found that requisition notices by ACE Holdings' wholly owned subsidiary, ACE Credit (M) Sdn Bhd, nominated two individuals as directors of Apex Equity Holdings Bhd. Based on those findings, the High Court held that the SC had properly exercised its powers in imposing sanctions on ACE Holdings for breaches under Section 152(2)(a) of the SCMA read together with Section 354(1)(a) of the CMSA, for making false and/or misleading statements to the SC.
The court then ordered ACE Holdings to pay RM10,000 in costs to the SC. ACE Holdings was represented by Muhammad Farhan Shafee of Messrs Shafee & Co, while the SC was represented by Lee Shih of Messrs Lim Chee Wee Partnership, together with Charles Chong and Sarah Chin.
Implications for the ACE dispute and market oversight
The judicial review application was filed three years ago to challenge the SC's decision, after leave to commence the review was granted on 18 July 2023 by then-judge Datuk Ahmad Kamal Md Shahid, now a Court of Appeal judge. In judicial review applications against government authorities, prior leave is required before the merits of a challenge can be heard, to ensure that the action is not frivolous, vexatious or an abuse of the court process.ACE Holdings' main argument was that the SC's decision to impose a penalty under Section 354(4) of the CMSA read together with Section 152(2)(a) of the Securities Commission Act 1993 was beyond the bounds of the law. According to the SC's website, the regulator reprimanded ACE Group over its investment scheme in December 2018 and stated that ACE Holdings had breached the CMSA through private placement information memorandums dated 8 Sept 2015 and 5 Jan 2018 that contained false or misleading information.
The disputed information concerned ACE Credit's issued and paid-up capital, the target amount of funds to be raised, the use of proceeds, and ACE Holdings' track record in fundraising. The case is also part of a broader dispute between ACE Holdings and the SC over the previous acquisition of shares in Apex Equity, the owner of Apex Securities Bhd, which was subsequently disposed of by ACE Holdings.
In a filing dated 1 Dec 2022, Apex Equity said the SC was seeking a court declaration that its subsidiary, Apex Securities, had breached securities laws and that ACE Holdings, which is part of ACE Group, had knowingly participated in those breaches. The SC alleged that Apex Securities breached securities laws because ACE had become the controller of Apex Securities even though ACE was not a fit and proper party to do so.
In our previous report on the case involving former Felda Investment Corp (FIC) chief executive Mohd Zaid Abdul Jalil, he pleaded not guilty to charges of deceiving the board of directors in relation to the appointment of a developer and land valuation for the Jalan Semarak project. We highlighted how the allegations renewed focus on management accountability, transparency in internal approval processes, and governance risks in high-value asset transactions involving government-linked entities.