UK state wealth fund faces scrutiny over investments in privately financeable projects
Britain's National Wealth Fund is drawing criticism over whether taxpayer-backed capital is being directed to projects that genuinely lack private financing. The debate has intensified as the fund expands its firepower and backs assets ranging from ports and power grids to defence companies and water infrastructure.
Highlights
- Critics question National Wealth Fund's £200mn June loan to profitable Associated British Ports, citing the group's £10bn valuation and ability to raise private capital.
- The Fund's £1.2bn loan to ScottishPower, £800mn guarantee to SSEN Transmission, and £300mn guarantee for United Utilities' Haweswater project raise concerns over crowding out private investment.
- Chancellor John Healey added £15.4bn to the Fund in June, bringing total capital to £43.2bn with £11bn already committed and an investment deployment target of £100mn per week.
Criticism over port, grid and utility funding
As reported by Financial Times, critics say several National Wealth Fund investments appear to support mature, profitable businesses and regulated infrastructure groups that could raise money without state help.One example is a £200mn loan agreed in June for Associated British Ports to help fund upgrades at Immingham, England's largest port by tonnage, including a new freight terminal. ABP handles 46mn tonnes of cargo a year, is owned by international investors, is profitable and was recently valued at more than £10bn, prompting critics to question whether public money should be used for work its owners could finance themselves.
Andrew Truscott, chief executive of infrastructure investor John Laing, said public funding should be reserved for projects that would not happen otherwise. He argued the UK remains attractive to private investors and that well-structured projects can still secure commercial backing on their own.
The same concern extends to the fund's support for other infrastructure groups. Its renewable energy and network commitments include a £1.2bn loan to Iberdrola-owned ScottishPower and an £800mn guarantee to SSEN Transmission, while it has also provided a £300mn guarantee to support financing for United Utilities' £3bn Haweswater Aqueduct refurbishment.
Richard Threlfall, a consultant and former global head of infrastructure for KPMG, said mature, privately owned utilities controlling regulated assets should be funded entirely by commercial markets. Two people close to the Haweswater project said fundraising there was heavily oversubscribed, suggesting the fund risked crowding out private capital, although the NWF disputes that claim.
Mandate, scale and questions over taxpayer returns
The criticism also reflects wider questions about the fund's role as it seeks both to unlock investment and generate a return for the Treasury. Opponents say that requirement may steer it towards large, bankable assets rather than earlier-stage projects where state backing could have a clearer catalytic effect.Threlfall pointed instead to a £38.4mn loan to Edinburgh Council for enabling works on a waterfront regeneration scheme as a more appropriate use of public capital. Sir Dieter Helm, an infrastructure expert at the University of Oxford, said the fund shows little coherence in its investment choices and questioned whether it represents the best use of scarce public resources while core infrastructure is deteriorating.
The fund has also backed established growth businesses through its equity portfolio, including a £25mn investment in Bristol-based defence engineering company Rowden in May. NWF chair Chris Grigg said such investments support UK reindustrialisation and defence capacity, while increasing the chances that companies remain and expand in the UK.
Pressure on deployment is rising as the fund's resources grow. Last month it received an additional £15.4bn in Chancellor John Healey's Budget, taking total capital to £43.2bn, with £11bn already committed, and chief executive Oliver Holbourn has said he aims to deploy about £100mn each week.
Noah Law, a Labour MP with development finance experience, said smaller but important projects may be harder to pursue at scale because they require substantial due diligence capacity. The NWF says its capital deepens available financing, helps prevent debt costs from rising and is designed to address technology, revenue, policy and long-term financing risks that private markets cannot always absorb alone, while ABP says the fund's long-term approach and strategic backing helped attract additional private funding.