HSBC reviews Palantir stake in $9bn Islamic equity fund after pension concerns

HSBC reviews Palantir stake in $9bn Islamic equity fund after pension concerns
HSBC reviews Palantir stake

Pressure is building on a major sharia-compliant equity fund after UK workplace pension schemes questioned its exposure to Palantir. The review follows HSBC Asset Management's March benchmark switch, which led the fund to buy $38.3 million of shares in the U.S. software company in the first half of the year.

Highlights

  • HSBC Asset Management reviews Palantir's inclusion in its $9 billion Islamic Global Equity Index fund after client objections from UK pension schemes Nest and People’s Pension.
  • HSBC switched the fund’s benchmark from the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index to the S&P Global 1200 Shariah Select Index in March, resulting in $38.3 million of Palantir shares acquired in H1.
  • Palantir’s ties to U.S. and Israeli defense sectors and contract controversies in Europe have triggered backlash among investors seeking stricter adherence to sharia principles in fund holdings.

Fund review follows benchmark change and client objections

As first reported by Financial Times, HSBC Asset Management is reviewing whether Palantir should remain in its $9 billion Islamic Global Equity Index fund after concerns from some of the UK's largest workplace pension schemes.

The fund tracks the S&P Global 1200 Shariah Select Index and bought $38.3 million of Palantir shares in the first half of the year. HSBC switched the benchmark for the fund from the Dow Jones Islamic Market Titans 100 Index in March, a change that altered the portfolio's holdings.

Nest, the UK state-backed workplace pension scheme, says its senior executives have begun discussions with HSBC Asset Management after receiving queries about Palantir's inclusion. People’s Pension, which has more than 7 million members, has also contacted the asset manager, according to people familiar with the matter.

HSBC says it will assess whether the current approach still meets investors' expectations. The asset manager adds that it takes client concerns seriously and will review the matter carefully.

Palantir controversy tests investor expectations for sharia funds

Palantir remains a contentious holding because of its ties to the U.S. and Israeli defence industries. The company has also faced backlash in Europe, where government agencies in Switzerland, Germany and France have rejected or replaced its tools.

Earlier this year, London mayor Lord Sadiq Khan blocked a £50 million contract with the Metropolitan Police, although the mayor's office says the decision was not based on the company's values or ethics. Nest had about 40,000 members invested in the HSBC fund and had received a small handful of inquiries about the holding, one person familiar with the situation says.

Sharia-compliant funds follow Islamic legal and ethical principles, but differences between benchmark indices can still lead to broad variations in underlying holdings. Umer Suleman, a board member at Islamic Finance Council UK, says several investors in the fund approached him with what he described as genuine outrage and shock over Palantir's inclusion.

Palantir does not immediately respond to a request for comment.

Our earlier report on the Trans-Caspian Enterprise Fund examined ethics concerns around Konstantin Sokolov, who was appointed to oversee U.S. development capital across the South Caucasus and Central Asia while holding significant business interests in Armenia. We outlined warnings from ethics experts about potential conflicts of interest and noted questions raised about his past links to a Russia-focused investment firm, highlighting how oversight and mandate alignment can become contentious when stakeholder expectations are challenged.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.