Texas Democrats secure Senate upset as Musk-backed Paxton campaign falls short
Democrats break a more than three-decade losing streak in Texas Senate races after James Talarico defeats Republican Ken Paxton in one of the country’s costliest contests. The result also undercuts Elon Musk’s political spending in the state after his PAC pours $47mn into backing Paxton and Musk uses X to amplify attacks on Talarico during the campaign.
Highlights
- Talarico wins the Texas Senate race despite Republican and Elon Musk backing for Paxton, in a contest costing over $430mn according to AdImpact.
- Musk's PAC contributes $47mn directly to Paxton’s campaign and $158mn to the Senate Leadership Fund, yet fails to secure the seat for Republicans.
- Talarico frames Musk's heavy spending as a campaign issue, with voters signaling opposition to billionaire influence in Texas politics despite Musk's major business presence in the state.
Costly Texas race exposes limits of Musk’s political spending
As reported by Financial Times, Talarico’s victory delivers a setback not only to Paxton but also to Musk, who has tied much of his business presence to Texas and invests heavily in the Republican’s bid. The race costs more than $430mn overall, according to ad-tracking firm AdImpact, making it the second most expensive Senate contest in the country, with Republicans accounting for most of the spending.Musk’s PAC contributes $47mn to the Texas Senate race and, in September, $158mn to the Senate Leadership Fund, the main Republican Senate Super Pac. During the campaign, Musk also uses X to promote attacks on Talarico, including an early October post saying, “There is something deeply wrong with Talarico,” amid an online conspiracy about the Democrat’s absence from the trail.
Talarico turns Musk’s involvement into a campaign issue. Responding to the billionaire’s criticism, the 37-year-old says there is “something deeply wrong with a political system that allows one trillionaire to buy his own personal U.S. Senator,” and in his acceptance speech on Wednesday he says voters send a message to “every billionaire mega-donor”.
Texas political fallout and regional implications
Musk’s backing serves as a financial lifeline for Paxton after Senate Republicans spend heavily on veteran senator John Cornyn in the primaries and then decline to fully support Paxton after Donald Trump gives him a late endorsement. Mark Jones, a political science professor at Rice University in Houston, says Paxton’s campaign would otherwise have been largely without financial backing.Jones also says Musk’s money helps Paxton fund a late wave of attack ads focused on Talarico’s past comments on trans youth and immigration. Brandon Rottinghaus, a politics professor at the University of Houston, says the support keeps Paxton afloat but also gives Talarico fresh ammunition to argue that Musk is trying to buy the seat.
The result carries broader implications for Texas, where Musk has expanded his footprint since relocating Tesla’s headquarters to the state. He roots major operations there, including SpaceX’s headquarters at Starbase in South Texas and facilities linked to his tunnelling business, but some voters remain sceptical of his political role; Vishal Patel, a Bastrop resident voting Democratic for the first time, says Musk is likely to expect something in return because “there is no such thing as free money.”
Our earlier article on Republicans’ late-campaign advertising surge described how tightening polls drove a sharp jump in ad spending across Senate and House races. We noted that Texas had become the costliest Senate contest of the cycle, with hundreds of millions poured into advertising as Democrat James Talarico held a narrow polling edge over Republican Ken Paxton.