Weiss Ratings says scaffold safety laws could cut construction deaths and costs across U.S. states
A new construction safety analysis points to large potential economic and human gains if more states adopt liability rules modeled on New York's Scaffold Safety Law. The report says the policy framework is linked to sharply lower injury and fatality rates in New York than in Pennsylvania, even after adjusting for New York's heavier concentration of high-rise and multifamily building activity.
Highlights
- New York's Scaffold Safety Law helped lower construction fatalities to 8.9 per 100,000 workers in 2024, versus Pennsylvania's adjusted 37.6.
- Report estimates New York would see 36,971 more injuries and 112 more deaths annually if injury and fatality rates matched Pennsylvania’s adjusted levels.
- Stricter scaffold safety rules in New York save an estimated $1.356 billion annually in direct economic costs, primarily from lost-time injuries and fatalities.
Report compares New York and Pennsylvania safety outcomes
As reported by Weiss Ratings, a study prepared for the New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health compares New York's construction safety record with Pennsylvania's and argues that similar laws elsewhere could prevent thousands of injuries and hundreds of deaths.The report says New York's Scaffold Safety Law, also known as Labor Law §240, places liability for elevation-related injuries on owners and contractors that fail to provide proper scaffolding, ladders, hoists and other safety devices. It argues that this creates a direct financial incentive to install fall protection before work begins, rather than relying mainly on regulatory inspections.
Falls remain the leading hazard on building sites. The New York City Department of Buildings reports that more than half of construction injuries and work-site fatalities recorded in 2024 result from falls.
Using official 2024 data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Census Bureau, the analysis adjusts Pennsylvania's accident rates to account for New York's much larger share of multifamily and high-rise construction. In 2024, New York authorizes 876 new units in buildings of five or more units for every 10,000 construction workers, compared with 277 in Pennsylvania.
On that basis, New York records an estimated 137 construction injuries per 10,000 full-time-equivalent workers, while Pennsylvania's adjusted injury index reaches 1,084. New York also records 8.9 construction fatalities per 100,000 full-time-equivalent workers, versus an adjusted Pennsylvania fatality index of 37.6.
Economic case for wider adoption
To illustrate the scale of the gap, the report applies Pennsylvania's adjusted rates to New York's construction workforce of about 390,400 workers. It says that matching Pennsylvania's adjusted injury rate would imply 36,971 additional injuries a year, while matching its adjusted fatality rate would imply 112 additional deaths.Using National Safety Council benchmarks and counting only injuries serious enough to keep a worker off the job, the report estimates the added annual burden at about $1.356 billion in New York alone. That total includes $1.183 billion tied to 24,647 additional lost-time injuries and $172.5 million linked to 112 additional deaths.
The analysis says those figures exclude harder-to-measure costs such as long-term care, family caregiving, project delays and burdens on public disability and health programs. It also argues that the totals far exceed measurable insurance costs, citing the New York City Housing Authority's 2023 project-cost model, in which all insurance accounts for about 1% of construction costs, and an industry-funded Rockefeller study that estimates annual §240-specific claims and legal costs at roughly $110 million.
Weiss Ratings founder Dr. Martin D. Weiss says New York's experience offers a tested policy model for legislatures seeking to lower construction deaths and reduce related economic losses. The report argues that if states without comparable protections adopt similar rules, the cumulative effect over time could amount to hundreds of lives saved and billions of dollars avoided across the U.S.
We have also analyzed home care liability and how directly hiring carers can leave families responsible for injury-related insurance cover.