Bank of England study links lower vacancy posting costs to shifts in UK labour market tightness
Long-term changes in how employers advertise jobs are reshaping one of the labour market indicators most closely watched for wage pressure and monetary policy. A new Bank of England paper says the rise in the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio increasingly reflects structural changes in hiring costs rather than only cyclical tightness.
Highlights
- Bank of England study finds declining vacancy posting costs, due to shift from print to online recruitment since 1982, have raised UK job postings.
- Researchers show higher vacancy-to-unemployment ratio may overstate UK labour market tightness if equilibrium vacancy levels increased structurally.
- Paper warns monetary policy could misjudge wage pressure and inflation risks if it fails to adjust vacancy-based slack estimates for lower posting costs.
Declining advertising costs reshape vacancy measures
As reported by Bank of England, the paper argues that falling vacancy posting costs help explain the secular rise in vacancies in the UK labour market over recent decades.The study focuses on the vacancy-to-unemployment ratio, or V/U, a common gauge of labour market tightness. It says that ratio has trended higher over time, creating a measurement problem if the equilibrium level of vacancies has also shifted.
To address that issue, the authors construct a new long-run measure of vacancy posting costs using recruitment advertising expenditure data dating back to 1982. The series shows a substantial decline in real posting costs after recruitment moved from print-based advertising to online hiring platforms.
Implications for policy and labour market analysis
By incorporating the new cost measure into estimates of equilibrium vacancy creation, the paper finds that a substantial share of the increase in vacancies reflects structural rather than cyclical developments.That distinction matters for policymakers because labour market tightness is a key determinant of wage pressure and an important input into monetary policy decisions. If raw vacancy data overstate underlying tightness, estimates of labour market slack and the inflation signals drawn from them may need to be interpreted with more caution.
Earlier, we discussed BoE risk outlook themes from AI investment, energy uncertainty and hedge-fund leverage affecting UK rates expectations.