Wall Street volatility signals muted hedging as stock selloff deepens

Traders Union
All News
Stocks
Wall Street volatility muted

Highlights

Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) closed at 19.4 after a 2.2-point move despite S&P 500 dropping nearly 2%, signaling restrained volatility reaction.
Nasdaq 100 options implied volatility increased broadly after the Oct. 16 selloff, but out-of-the-money options (20%-50% OTM) saw subdued demand for protection.
Morgan Stanley data show global gross equity exposure among long-short active managers is down 8%, the largest drawdown in at least a decade, indicating major de-leveraging.

Options market reaction stays restrained

As reported by CNBC, several options analysts say the latest equity selloff is not triggering the kind of aggressive hedging that usually lifts implied volatility more sharply.

The Cboe Volatility Index, or VIX, reaches its highest intraday level since April on Friday but then retreats to close at 19.4, even as the S&P 500 ends the day down nearly 2%. Brent Kochuba of SpotGamma says the 2.2-point rise in the VIX is relatively muted for a move of that size, with his study of 126 selloffs since 2018 indicating the index would typically rise closer to 2.6 points.

Analysts also point to selective rather than broad-based demand for protection. Data shared by Nasdaq's Kevin Davitt shows implied volatility rises for most Nasdaq 100 options contracts, but contracts 20% to 50% out of the money stand out as key exceptions after the Oct. 16 selloff.

Nomura managing director Charlie McElligott writes that out-of-the-money S&P 500 puts are not being heavily chased at the moment, a sign that investors remain comparatively calm despite falling share prices. He adds that index options skew has not been particularly reactive to the recent drop in spot equities, and where it has moved, part of the change reflects softer call volatility.

De-leveraging may explain investor calm

One explanation for the muted hedging demand is that asset managers are selling stocks quickly instead of using options to protect existing positions against further declines.

A widely circulated chart over the weekend from Morgan Stanley's prime brokerage shows total global gross equity exposure among long-short active managers is down 8% from its most recent peak, the biggest drawdown in at least 10 years.

Zed Francis, chief investment officer at Chicago-based Convexitas, says long-short investors are going through a major de-leveraging event, buying back shorts and selling longs. If portfolios are moved closer to cash, he says, the need to hedge through options falls, helping explain why implied volatility remains quiet during a month of higher market stress.

Our earlier SPX price analysis covered the S&P 500’s pullback amid earnings-driven moves in tech and AI stocks and pressure from rising Treasury yields. We noted that the index was trading below key 20- and 50-day moving averages, pointing to short- and medium-term selling pressure, with a likely near-term consolidation range. The piece also highlighted key levels to watch—resistance around 7,699 and support near 7,678—as potential triggers for the next directional move.

This material may contain third-party opinions, none of the data and information on this webpage constitutes investment advice according to our Disclaimer. While we adhere to strict Editorial Integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners.