Choosing Between Forex And Stocks: Which Market Is Better To Trade?
Forex markets offer high liquidity, 24/5 availability, and the ability to profit from both rising and falling markets, but they come with a higher degree of leverage and can be more affected by geopolitical events. Stock markets involve trading shares of companies, providing ownership in a company, potential dividends, and a generally lower level of leverage, but they typically are more influenced by individual company performance and economic factors.
Forex and stock trading offer distinct opportunities and challenges for active traders. While both markets allow participants to capitalize on price movements, their characteristics differ in accessibility, trading hours, and costs. Forex offers more accessibility and trading hours and is also lower in cost. Forex traders can also benefit from stock trading through CFD trading. With CFD, you can access the stock market as quickly as the Forex market. Although there are some drawbacks to trading stocks as CFDs, the benefits outweigh them.
What is the Forex market?
The foreign exchange market, more commonly known as “Forex”, is the largest and most liquid financial trading arena in the world. On a daily basis, trillions of dollars worth of currencies change hands as participants leverage its decentralized structure to buy, sell and exchange the monetary values of different nations.
At its foundation, the Forex market serves a critical economic purpose - it facilitates global trade and investment flows by enabling convenient currency conversion across international borders. This keeps the wheels of global commerce well-lubricated. Major players like banks, brokers, asset managers and corporations actively trade within its depths, both speculatively and to hedge their currency risk exposures.
Yet the Forex market is more than just a mechanism. Its vast scale means it absorbs influences from all corners of the globe. Economic data, political developments, commodity price shifts - all ultimately permeate Forex markets as traders weigh their implications for supply and demand across currencies. Underlying everything is a complex interplay between macro-level factors, geopolitical currents and psychological market sentiment. Their fluctuating tides determine currency pricing movements from moment to moment.
In this way, the Forex arena exists at the intersection of finance, economics and worldwide affairs. It provides a real-time barometer for measuring the rhythms of international cooperation and competition that define our modern, interconnected global system. For the savvy retail trader, it presents an opportunity to profit from their insightful analysis and predictive acumen regarding these powerful macro trends and forces.
What is the stock market?
The stock market lies at the heart of capitalism, serving as the primary mechanism for companies to raise funds and investors to gain exposure to business growth. Often called simply "the market", it encompasses the various exchanges and over-the-counter markets where shares of publicly listed companies are actively traded.
Stocks, also known as shares or equities, represent fractional ownership in a corporation. When companies wish to expand operations or simply have capital for day-to-day activities, they may offer new shares to investors through public offerings. This provides companies with much-needed cash in exchange for granting shareholders a stake in future profits.
Both large institutions and everyday retail traders participate in the stock market. Brokers enable anyone to buy and sell stocks with just a click of a button from any internet-connected device. Behind the scenes, professional fund managers, analysts and proprietary trading firms also operate, seeking to outsmart other investors and earn returns.
A company's share price fluctuates constantly based on supply and demand as well as market perceptions of its prospects and performance. Economic conditions, competition, new products or controversies can all impact this valuation. Therefore, insightful stock pickers research firms deeply and track various indicators to try and identify undervalued opportunities before the crowd - or anticipate upcoming declines.
In its simplest form, the stock market is a vehicle for companies to access growth capital and investors to share in business success over the long haul. It thus plays a vital role in fueling corporate innovation and development worldwide.
Forex vs Stocks - Which is More Profitable?
One of the key questions for beginning traders is which market offers the best opportunities to generate substantial returns - Forex or stocks. However, there is no definitive answer as profitability depends more on the individual and strategy employed rather than the asset class itself. Both present opportunities to realize gains as well as risks of loss if not approached properly.
On the surface, the massive daily Forex volume seems to provide ample chance for profit grabbing given frequent small movements. However, its tremendous leverage cuts both ways - while amplifying potential gains, it just as easily magnifies losses. Meanwhile, compelling long-term stock growth narratives and ability to hold winning positions longer often allow for larger percentage increases before giving gains back to the market.
Ultimately, either market can prove vastly profitable or unprofitable based on the trader. Critical factors in success include education, strategy selection, risk management techniques, capital base, market behavior knowledge and emotional discipline. Focusing on survivors' biases - what patterns do continually profitable traders adhere to - provides lessons applicable to both arenas.
Overall, any claims of one market's superior ability to generate income are spurious without acknowledging the importance of the individual and their applied approach. What differentiates "paper" from "real" profits lies not in chosen instruments, but rather one's developed methodology and its context-appropriate application over numerous trading cycles. With dedication to learning and improvement, traders can find lucrative opportunities regardless of market domain.
Differences between Forex trading and stock trading
Let's delve into more detail by first examining some major differences between Forex trading and stock trading.
Accessibility and market size
The Forex trading market has a low entry barrier since it requires little capital. Many brokers require just $10 to $100 to be able to trade Forex on their platforms, and you don’t always have to execute the trades with standard lot sizes as they provide micro and mini lot sizes, which are more suitable for traders with small account balances.
The market has a daily volume of over 7.5 trillion, accounting for trades involving various currencies worldwide. These currencies are divided into major, minor, and exotic, paired to form the base and quote currencies. For example, a combination of the Great Britain Pound and the United States Dollar will form a GBP/USD pair, with GBP being the base currency and the USD being the quoted currency.
On the other hand, the stock market requires a higher minimum capital requirement, with a typical minimum of 100 shares per trade. Thus, you will need substantial capital to buy a meaningful number of stocks. The number of stocks available to trade on any given exchange is limited to those companies listed on it. Major exchanges like the NYSE and NASDAQ have several thousand listings each. However, daily trading volume in the combined global stock markets is sizable but still significantly smaller than the over 7.5 trillion daily volume in Forex.
Leverage differences
Leverage allows traders to control larger positions than is possible with the capital in their accounts. With leverage, you can trade with more money than you deposited, magnifying profits and losses. Therefore, understanding how to use leverage wisely is critical.
Forex brokers typically offer very high leverage, such as 1:1,000 or even 1:2,000 (some regulators don’t allow leverage as high as that). This means you can multiply your position size and potentially make more money with less capital.
Conversely, stock trading generally offers little to no leverage. Which means you will need to deposit more capital to make substantial profits. For example, a Forex trader with $1,000 capital using 1:100 leverage could control a $100,000 position size (their $1,000 capital multiplied by the 100x leverage). In contrast, a stock trader with just $1,000 without using leverage would be limited to making a profit on top of that $1,000. If their trade moves 10% in their speculated direction, they would only make $100 profit.
Trading hours
The Forex market is open for trading around the clock from Monday to Friday. The market typically closes to retail traders during the weekends and holidays, but this does not mean there is a total absence of activity since the main factors that drive the market are still active. Despite the 24-hour market availability, the Forex market is also divided into market hours and sessions, when specific currencies are most active and well traded.
For example, the Great Britain Pounds and Euro are active during the London session from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. (GMT) Monday to Friday. The United States dollar and Canadian dollar are most active from 1 p.m. to 9 p.m.; referred to as the New York session. The Asian and Sydney sessions are when currencies like the Chinese Yuan, Japanese Yen, and Singapore Dollar are most active. The Asian session is open between 11 p.m. and 5 a.m., while the Sydney session opens an hour before the Asian session, and they close at the same time. If you look closely, you will see an overlap between the London session and the first hours of the New York session. This overlap represents the times that typically have the highest volume in the Forex market since the world’s heaviest and most traded currencies are active at that time.
On the other hand, the stock market has set trading hours and is usually closed on weekends and holidays. The trading hours are usually determined by the country and exchange in which they are listed. For example, the New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ are open from 1:30 p.m. to 8:30 p.m. GMT from Monday to Friday.
Trading costs and fees
Traders pay broker fees to access online trading platforms. These fees can be flat rates or percentages of transactions in the form of spreads or commissions. Spreads are usually either floating or fixed. Floating spreads change with market volatility, generally widening as volatility decreases, raising costs, while fixed spreads remain constant regardless of volatility. Commissions are usually in the form of preset fees per trade. Other fees charged for online trading include deposit and withdrawal fees, inactivity fees, and swap fees, among others. The costs are usually broker specific.
Stock trading also incurs fees, often higher than Forex. Stock brokers charge exchange fees for executing orders and providing market data. These can add up rapidly, especially for high-frequency traders. There are also some broker and exchange specific fees involved in the process.
The costs incurred during Forex and stock trading depend on the broker, country, instruments traded, and other factors. However, the former’s fees tend to be lower overall than the latter’s.
Best Forex brokers
Best stock brokers
CFDs: Trading stocks on Forex
Contracts for Difference (CFDs) are derivative instruments that give traders exposure to underlying assets like stocks, indices, commodities, and currencies without owning them. CFDs are commonly used in Forex trading as they allow speculation on currency pairs without taking ownership of the actual currencies. Intriguingly, CFDs also present an alternative way to trade stocks compared to traditional buying and holding for profit. For Forex traders interested in stock market exposure without directly buying shares, trading stocks through CFDs can be an appealing option. The key benefit is that traders can speculate on stock price movements without needing to purchase and sell the underlying equities.
Advantages of trading stocks on Forex
The following are some of the advantages of trading stocks on Forex:
-
Convenient to trade
CFDs provide easy access to trading major stocks without needing to open separate share-dealing accounts. Many CFD platforms integrate stocks alongside currencies and other assets. -
CFDs provide access to high leverage.
CFD brokers offer leverage exceeding traditional stock brokers, allowing greater market exposure with limited capital. With leverage, you can still trade stocks and make a lot of money with a small deposit. -
Simplified short selling
Short selling stocks through CFDs is much more straightforward compared to traditional short selling of equities. Traditional short selling faces restrictions and challenges when borrowing less liquid stocks to short.CFDs remove these barriers to shorting stocks. There are no hard-to-borrow fees or liquidity constraints. The CFD broker handles the hedging internally, while the trader simply executes a sell order as with any other position.
-
You can’t lose more than your deposit
With CFDs, losses are limited to the capital invested in a position, unlike direct stock investing, where prices could fall indefinitely. CFD brokers offer negative balance protection, restricting losses to the trader’s account balance even in volatile markets.In contrast, share values have a theoretically unlimited downside if the company fails. While direct stock investors are also limited by their invested capital, their shares could become worthless if the stock falls to zero.
Drawbacks that come with trading stocks on Forex
Now let’s look at some of the disadvantages of trading stocks on Forex:
-
No shares or dividends
CSince you are not holding the underlying asset of the stocks, you won’t have access to any dividends paid by the company for the number of shares you hold. You also won’t have any voting privileges for major decision-making about the company stocks, which you could access if you hold the underlying asset. -
Funding costs
Leverage helps you get greater exposure to the market without depositing a lot of money. However, there is a cost for the leverage, which is what funding fees are. For each day you have open positions, you will be charged some fees based on the leverage used. If you are not careful, these fees can easily affect your overall profit. You won’t have to pay such fees if you own the actual shares.Overall, CFDs provide an efficient way to trade stock exposure using the leverage and directional trading that Forex traders are accustomed to. But risks like volatility and counterparty risk remain.
For Forex traders interested in equity markets, check out this guide comparing CFDs and stocks. The article provides an in-depth look at the pros, cons, risks, and mechanics of trading CFDs versus traditional stocks.
Should you trade Forex or stocks?
When choosing between pursuing opportunities in the Forex or stock markets, aspiring traders must carefully evaluate their own strengths as well as how each arena may suit different styles.
The foreign exchange market appeals to those with a global macroeconomic mindset, as currency speculation requires digesting a wide array of international economic indicators to capitalize on fleeting exchange rate divergences.
Meanwhile, the stock market is better suited for fundamental analysts adept at meticulous company research and showing patience amid short-term volatility.
For day traders focusing solely on short-term technical trading opportunities, technical analysis provides an array of tools to help identify signals both in Forex and stock trading. Tools like moving averages, indicators of momentum and volume, as well as common chart patterns can help uncover signs of buying or selling pressure. This allows traders to pinpoint potential trend reversals or spikes in volatility.
Mastery of technicals gives traders an edge in both markets through spotting early signals and allowing maximum profit potential by pinpointing high-probability entries and exits within minutes or hours. Backtesting allows refining indicator interpretations tailored for each environment. While fundamentals may drive longer-term direction, technicals provide an advantage in volatile day trading arenas.
In summary, the skilled currency speculator thrives on synthesizing diverse macroeconomic stimuli and pouncing on transient dislocations between monetary values. Meanwhile, the gifted equity investor focuses on discernibly gauging companies' underlying worth and backing promising ventures for years to maximize returns. Candid self-assessment of one's attributes, risk tolerance and aims will determine the most appropriate path to potential profit and preferred time horizons. Both arenas demand diligence, but offer financial rewards to adept participants.
FAQs
Which market is regulated better?
The level of regulation for both the Forex and stock markets can vary significantly depending on the country or jurisdiction in which they operate. The stock market is highly regulated in most countries, with commissions like the Securities and Exchange Commission in the United States and the Financial Conduct Authority of the United Kingdom overseeing the operations of exchanges. The Forex market is also regulated by commissions in various jurisdictions but tends to be less centralized than the stock market.
Is Forex or stocks better for beginners?
The choice of which is better between Forex trading and stock trading depends on your personal preference, goals, risk tolerance, and time. However, one could argue that the stock market is better because it provides lower leverage, predictable volatility, and limited trading hours that can help beginners to not overtrade.
Which is easier to trade, Forex or stocks?
The ease of trading between stocks and Forex is subjective, and it also depends on the trader’s preference, trading style, and convenience. Stocks have available data, like financial statements, metrics, and news events, that can aid analysis. The Forex market also provides data and news that can support the trader’s technical analysis. The choice of which is easier would depend on which the potential trader can put up with easily.
Can traders use automated trading systems in both Forex and stock markets?
Yes, Forex and stock traders can automate their trades, a practice also known as algorithmic trading. However, stock market regulations tend to be stricter around automated and high-frequency trading practices.
Team that worked on the article
Alamin Morshed is a contributor at Traders Union. He specializes in writing articles for businesses who want to improve their Google search rankings to compete with their competition.
Over the past four years, Alamin has been working independently and through online employment platforms such as Upwork and Fiverr, and also contributing to some reputable blogs. His goal is to balance informative content and provide an entertaining read to his readers.
His motto is: I can dream or I can do—I choose action.
Dr. BJ Johnson is a PhD in English Language and an editor with over 15 years of experience. He earned his degree in English Language in the U.S and the UK. In 2020, Dr. Johnson joined the Traders Union team. Since then, he has created over 100 exclusive articles and edited over 300 articles of other authors.
The topics he covers include trading signals, cryptocurrencies, Forex brokers, stock brokers, expert advisors, binary options. He has also worked on the ratings of brokers and many other materials.
Dr. BJ Johnson’s motto: It always seems impossible until it’s done. You can do it.
Mirjan Hipolito is a journalist and news editor at Traders Union. She is an expert crypto writer with five years of experience in the financial markets. Her specialties are daily market news, price predictions, and Initial Coin Offerings (ICO). Mirjan is a cryptocurrency and stock trader. This deep understanding of the finance sector allows her to create informative and engaging content that helps readers easily navigate the complexities of the crypto world.